FREE NEJM E-TOC    HOME   |   SUBSCRIBE   |   CURRENT ISSUE   |   PAST ISSUES   |   COLLECTIONS   |   Search Term  Advanced Search

Sign in | Get NEJM's E-Mail Table of Contents — Free | Subscribe

Previous Volume 305:6-11 July 2, 1981 Number 1 Next

	Add to Personal Archive Add to Citation Manager Notify a Friend E-mail When Cited PubMed Citation

Abstract

From 1973 to 1980, we carried out a controlled study at the National Cancer Institute in Milan to consider the value of a conservative procedure in patients with breast cancer of small size. We randomized 701 patients with breast cancer measuring less than 2 cm in diameter and with no palpable axillary lymph nodes to Halsted radical mastectomy or to "quadrantectomy" with axillary dissection and radiotherapy to the ipsilateral residual breast tissue. We treated 349 patients with Halsted mastectomy and 352 with quadrantectomy. The two groups were comparable in age distribution, size and site of primary tumor, menopausal status, and frequency of axillary metastases. There were three local recurrences in the Halsted group and one in the quadrantectomy group. Actuarial curves showed no difference between the two groups in disease-free or overall survival. From these results, mastectomy appears to involve unnecessary mutilation in patients with breast cancer of less than 2 cm and no palpable axillary nodes.

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Torzilli, G., Donadon, M., Marconi, M., Palmisano, A., Del Fabbro, D., Spinelli, A., Botea, F., Montorsi, M. (2008). Hepatectomy for Stage B and Stage C Hepatocellular Carcinoma in the Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer Classification: Results of a Prospective Analysis. Arch Surg 143: 1082-1090 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Kim, S. J., Ko, E. Y., Shin, J. H., Kang, S. S., Mun, S. H., Han, B.-K., Cho, E. Y. (2008). Application of Sonographic BI-RADS to Synchronous Breast Nodules Detected in Patients with Breast Cancer. Am. J. Roentgenol. 191: 653-658 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Berwick, D. M. (2008). The Science of Improvement. JAMA 299: 1182-1184 [Full Text]  
• Tuttle, T. M., Habermann, E. B., Grund, E. H., Morris, T. J., Virnig, B. A. (2007). Increasing Use of Contralateral Prophylactic Mastectomy for Breast Cancer Patients: A Trend Toward More Aggressive Surgical Treatment. JCO 25: 5203-5209 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Parker, P. A., Youssef, A., Walker, S., Basen-Engquist, K., Cohen, L., Gritz, E. R., Wei, Q. X., Robb, G. L. (2007). Short-Term and Long-Term Psychosocial Adjustment and Quality of Life in Women Undergoing Different Surgical Procedures for Breast Cancer. Ann. Surg. Oncol. 14: 3078-3089 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Giacalone, P.-L., Roger, P., Dubon, O., El Gareh, N., Rihaoui, S., Taourel, P., Daures, J. P. (2007). Comparative Study of the Accuracy of Breast Resection in Oncoplastic Surgery and Quadrantectomy in Breast Cancer. Ann. Surg. Oncol. 14: 605-614 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Epstein, A. M. (2007). Pay for Performance at the Tipping Point. NEJM 356: 515-517 [Full Text]  
• McCarthy, E. P., Ngo, L. H., Roetzheim, R. G., Chirikos, T. N., Li, D., Drews, R. E., Iezzoni, L. I. (2006). Disparities in breast cancer treatment and survival for women with disabilities.. ANN INTERN MED 145: 637-645 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Mamounas, E. P. (2005). Continuing Evolution in Breast Cancer Surgical Management. JCO 23: 1603-1606 [Full Text]  
• Harris, J. R. (2005). Radiation Therapy for Invasive Breast Cancer: Not Just for Local Control. JCO 23: 1607-1608 [Full Text]  
• Whelan, T. J. (2005). Use of Conventional Radiation Therapy As Part of Breast-Conserving Treatment. JCO 23: 1718-1725 [Full Text]  
• Lucci, A., Shoher, A., Sherman, M. O., Azzizadeh, A. (2004). Assessment of the Current Medicare Reimbursement System for Breast Cancer Operations. Ann. Surg. Oncol. 11: 1037-1044 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Figueiredo, M. I., Cullen, J., Hwang, Y.-T., Rowland, J. H., Mandelblatt, J. S. (2004). Breast Cancer Treatment in Older Women: Does Getting What You Want Improve Your Long-Term Body Image and Mental Health?. JCO 22: 4002-4009 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Whelan, T., Levine, M., Willan, A., Gafni, A., Sanders, K., Mirsky, D., Chambers, S., O'Brien, M. A., Reid, S., Dubois, S. (2004). Effect of a Decision Aid on Knowledge and Treatment Decision Making for Breast Cancer Surgery: A Randomized Trial. JAMA 292: 435-441 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Joseph, K.-A., El-Tamer, M., Komenaka, I., Troxel, A., Ditkoff, B. A., Schnabel, F. (2004). Predictors of Nonsentinel Node Metastasis in Patients With Breast Cancer After Sentinel Node Metastasis. Arch Surg 139: 648-651 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Mamounas, E. P. (2003). NSABP Breast Cancer Clinical Trials: Recent Results and Future Directions. Clin Med Res 1: 309-326 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Hirsch, A. (2003). Integrative Tumor Board: Recurrent Breast Cancer or New Primary?. Integr Cancer Ther 2: 272-276  
• Ishida, T., Furuta, A., Moriya, T., Ohuchi, N. (2003). Pathological Assessment of Intraductal Spread of Carcinoma in Relation to Surgical Margin State in Breast-conserving Surgery. Jpn J Clin Oncol 33: 161-166 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Malin, J. L., Schuster, M. A., Kahn, K. A., Brook, R. H. (2002). Quality of Breast Cancer Care: What Do We Know?. JCO 20: 4381-4393 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Veronesi, U., Cascinelli, N., Mariani, L., Greco, M., Saccozzi, R., Luini, A., Aguilar, M., Marubini, E. (2002). Twenty-Year Follow-up of a Randomized Study Comparing Breast-Conserving Surgery with Radical Mastectomy for Early Breast Cancer. NEJM 347: 1227-1232 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Fisher, B., Anderson, S., Bryant, J., Margolese, R. G., Deutsch, M., Fisher, E. R., Jeong, J.-H., Wolmark, N. (2002). Twenty-Year Follow-up of a Randomized Trial Comparing Total Mastectomy, Lumpectomy, and Lumpectomy plus Irradiation for the Treatment of Invasive Breast Cancer. NEJM 347: 1233-1241 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Moon, W. K., Noh, D.-Y., Im, J.-G. (2002). Multifocal, Multicentric, and Contralateral Breast Cancers: Bilateral Whole-Breast US in the Preoperative Evaluation of Patients. Radiology 224: 569-576 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Bonadonna, G., Zambetti, M., Bumma, C., Donadio, M., Bolognesi, A., Robustelli della Cuna, G., Ambrosini, G., Lelli, G., Mansutti, M., Verderio, P., Valagussa, P. (2002). Multimodal treatment with primary single-agent epirubicin in operable breast cancer: 5-year experience of the Michelangelo Cooperative Group. Ann Oncol 13: 1049-1058 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Keating, N. L., Guadagnoli, E., Landrum, M. B., Borbas, C., Weeks, J. C. (2002). Treatment Decision Making in Early-Stage Breast Cancer: Should Surgeons Match Patients' Desired Level of Involvement?. JCO 20: 1473-1479 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Norman, S. A, Miller, L. T, Erikson, H B., Norman, M F., McCorkle, R. (2001). Development and Validation of a Telephone Questionnaire to Characterize Lymphedema in Women Treated for Breast Cancer. ptjournal 81: 1192-1205 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Morrow, M., White, J., Moughan, J., Owen, J., Pajack, T., Sylvester, J., Frank Wilson, J., Winchester, D. (2001). Factors Predicting the Use of Breast-Conserving Therapy in Stage I and II Breast Carcinoma. JCO 19: 2254-2262 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Voogd, A. C., Nielsen, M., Peterse, J. L., Blichert-Toft, M., Bartelink, H., Overgaard, M., van Tienhoven, G., Andersen, K. W., Sylvester, R. J., van Dongen, J. A. (2001). Differences in Risk Factors for Local and Distant Recurrence After Breast-Conserving Therapy or Mastectomy for Stage I and II Breast Cancer: Pooled Results of Two Large European Randomized Trials. JCO 19: 1688-1697 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Recht, A., Edge, S. B., Solin, L. J., Robinson, D. S., Estabrook, A., Fine, R. E., Fleming, G. F., Formenti, S., Hudis, C., Kirshner, J. J., Krause, D. A., Kuske, R. R., Langer, A. S., Sledge, G. W. Jr, Whelan, T. J., Pfister, D. G. (2001). Postmastectomy Radiotherapy: Clinical Practice Guidelines of the American Society of Clinical Oncology. JCO 19: 1539-1569 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Turner, B. C., Krajewski, S., Krajewska, M., Takayama, S., Gumbs, A. A., Carter, D., Rebbeck, T. R., Haffty, B. G., Reed, J. C. (2001). BAG-1: A Novel Biomarker Predicting Long-Term Survival in Early-Stage Breast Cancer. JCO 19: 992-1000 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• van Dongen, J. A., Voogd, A. C., Fentiman, I. S., Legrand, C., Sylvester, R. J., Tong, D., van der Schueren, E., Helle, P. A., van Zijl, K., Bartelink, H. (2000). Long-Term Results of a Randomized Trial Comparing Breast-Conserving Therapy With Mastectomy: European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer 10801 Trial. JNCI J Natl Cancer Inst 92: 1143-1150 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Coradini, D., Daidone, M. G., Boracchi, P., Biganzoli, E., Oriana, S., Bresciani, G., Pellizzaro, C., Tomasic, G., Di Fronzo, G., Marubini, E. (2000). Time-Dependent Relevance of Steroid Receptors in Breast Cancer. JCO 18: 2702-2709 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Edeiken, B. S., Fornage, B. D., Bedi, D. G., Singletary, S. E., Ibrahim, N. K., Strom, E. A., Holmes, F. (1999). US-guided Implantation of Metallic Markers for Permanent Localization of the Tumor Bed in Patients with Breast Cancer Who Undergo Preoperative Chemotherapy. Radiology 213: 895-900 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Turner, B. C., Harrold, E., Matloff, E., Smith, T., Gumbs, A. A., Beinfield, M., Ward, B., Skolnick, M., Glazer, P. M., Thomas, A., Haffty, B. G. (1999). BRCA1/BRCA2 Germline Mutations in Locally Recurrent Breast Cancer Patients After Lumpectomy and Radiation Therapy: Implications for Breast-Conserving Management in Patients With BRCA1/BRCA2 Mutations. JCO 17: 3017-3024 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Liljegren, G., Holmberg, L., Bergh, J., Lindgren, A., Tabar, L., Nordgren, H., Adami, H.O. (1999). 10-Year Results After Sector Resection With or Without Postoperative Radiotherapy for Stage I Breast Cancer: A Randomized Trial. JCO 17: 2326-2326 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Du, X., Riley, G. F., Potosky, A. L., Klabunde, C. N., Warren, J. L., Ballard-Barbash, R. (1999). Increase in the Use of Breast-Conserving Surgery. JAMA 282: 326-327 [Full Text]  
• Riley, G. F., Potosky, A. L., Klabunde, C. N., Warren, J. L., Ballard-Barbash, R. (1999). Stage at Diagnosis and Treatment Patterns Among Older Women With Breast Cancer: An HMO and Fee-for-Service Comparison. JAMA 281: 720-726 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Esserman, L., Hylton, N., Yassa, L., Barclay, J., Frankel, S., Sickles, E. (1999). Utility of Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Management of Breast Cancer: Evidence for Improved Preoperative Staging. JCO 17: 110-110 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Silverstein, M. J (1997). Recent advances: diagnosis and treatment of early breast cancer. BMJ 314: 1736-1736 [Full Text]  
• Lazovich, D., White, E., Thomas, D. B., Moe, R. E., Taplin, S. (1997). Change in the Use of Breast-Conserving Surgery in Western Washington After the 1990 NIH Consensus Development Conference. Arch Surg 132: 418-423 [Abstract]  
• Veronesi, U., Zurrida, S. (1996). Optimal Surgical Treatment of Breast Cancer. The Oncologist 1: 340-346 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Dent, D. M. (1996). Axillary Lymphadenectomy for Breast Cancer: Paradigm Shifts and Pragmatic Surgeons. Arch Surg 131: 1125-1127 [Abstract]  
• Nattinger, A. B., Hoffmann, R. G., Shapiro, R., Gottlieb, M. S., Goodwin, J. S. (1996). The Effect of Legislative Requirements on the Use of Breast-Conserving Surgery. NEJM 335: 1035-1041 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Guenther, J. M., Kirgan, D. M., Giuliano, A. E. (1996). Feasibility of Breast-Conserving Therapy for Younger Women With Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 131: 632-636 [Abstract]  
• Staren, E. D., Klepac, S., Smith, A. P., Hartsell, W. F., Segretti, J., Witt, T. R., Griem, K. L., Bines, S. D. (1996). The Dilemma of Delayed Cellulitis After Breast Conservation Therapy. Arch Surg 131: 651-654 [Abstract]  
• Krauss, G. L., Brandt, J., Campbell, M., Plate, C., Summerfield, M. (1996). Antiepileptic medication and oral contraceptive interactions: A national survey of neurologists and obstetricians. Neurology 46: 1534-1539 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Dale, P. S., Giuliano, A. E. (1996). Nipple-Areolar Preservation During Breast-Conserving Therapy for Subareolar Breast Carcinomas. Arch Surg 131: 430-433 [Abstract]  
• Van den Bogaert, W., van der Schueren, E. (1995). Surgery for Breast Cancer. NEJM 332: 64-64 [Full Text]  
• Veronesi, U., Luini, A., Del Vecchio, M., Greco, M., Galimberti, V., Merson, M., Rilke, F., Sacchini, V., Saccozzi, R., Savio, T., Zucali, R., Zurrida, S., Salvadori, B. (1993). Radiotherapy after Breast-Preserving Surgery in Women with Localized Cancer of the Breast. NEJM 328: 1587-1591 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Senofsky, G. M., Moffat, F. L. Jr, Davis, K., Masri, M. M., Clark, K. C., Robinson, D. S., Sabates, B., Ketcham, A. S. (1991). Total Axillary Lymphadenectomy in the Management of Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 126: 1336-1342 [Abstract]  
• Ngai, J. H., Zelles, G. W., Rumore, G. J., Sawicki, J. E., Godfrey, R. S. (1991). Breast Biopsy Techniques and Adequacy of Margins. Arch Surg 126: 1343-1347 [Abstract]  
• Wolberg, W. H. (1991). Surgical Options in 424 Patients With Primary Breast Cancer Without Systemic Metastases. Arch Surg 126: 817-820 [Abstract]  
• Thompson, W. R., Bowen, J. R., Dorman, B. A., Pricolo, V. E., Shahinian, T. K., Soderberg, C. H. Jr (1991). Mammographic Localization and Biopsy of Nonpalpable Breast Lesions: A 5-Year Study. Arch Surg 126: 730-734 [Abstract]  
• Siegel, B. M., Mayzel, K. A., Love, S. M. (1990). Level I and II Axillary Dissection in the Treatment of Early-Stage Breast Cancer: An Analysis of 259 Consecutive Patients. Arch Surg 125: 1144-1147 [Abstract]  
• Eberlein, T. J., Connolly, J. L., Schnitt, S. J., Recht, A., Osteen, R. T., Harris, J. R. (1990). Predictors of Local Recurrence Following Conservative Breast Surgery and Radiation Therapy: The Influence of Tumor Size. Arch Surg 125: 771-777 [Abstract]  
• Moffat, F. L., Ketcham, A. S., Robinson, D. S., Legaspi, A., Ghandur-Mnaymneh, L., Hilsenbeck, S. (1990). Segmental Mastectomy Without Radiotherapy for T1 and Small T2 Breast Carcinomas. Arch Surg 125: 364-369 [Abstract]  
• Gutman, H., Kersz, T., Barzilai, T., Haddad, M., Reiss, R. (1990). Achievements of Physical Therapy in Patients After Modified Radical Mastectomy Compared With Quadrantectomy, Axillary Dissection, and Radiation for Carcinoma of the Breast. Arch Surg 125: 389-391 [Abstract]  
• Steeves, R. A., Phromratanapongse, P., Wolberg, W. H., Tormey, D. C. (1989). Cosmesis and Local Control After Irradiation in Women Treated Conservatively for Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 124: 1369-1373 [Abstract]  
• Haffty, B. G., Goldberg, N. B., Rose, M., Heil, B., Fischer, D., Beinfield, M., McKhann, C., Weissberg, J. B. (1989). Conservative Surgery With Radiation Therapy in Clinical Stage I and II Breast Cancer: Results of a 20-Year Experience. Arch Surg 124: 1266-1270 [Abstract]  
• Johnson, C. H., van Heerden, J. A., Donohue, J. H., Martin, J. K. Jr, Jackson, I. T., Ilstrup, D. M. (1989). Oncological Aspects of Immediate Breast Reconstruction Following Mastectomy for Malignancy. Arch Surg 124: 819-824 [Abstract]  
• Frazier, T. G., Wong, R. W. Y., Rose, D. (1989). Implications of Accurate Pathologic Margins in the Treatment of Primary Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 124: 37-38 [Abstract]  
• Adye, B., Jolly, P. C., Bauermeister, D. E. (1988). The Role of Fine-Needle Aspiration in the Management of Solid Breast Masses. Arch Surg 123: 37-39 [Abstract]  
• Osteen, R. T., Connolly, J. L., Recht, A., Silver, B., Schnitt, S. J., Harris, J. R. (1987). Identification of Patients at High Risk for Local Recurrence After Conservative Surgery and Radiation Therapy for Stage I or II Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 122: 1248-1252 [Abstract]  
• Ghossein, N. A., Vilcoq, J., Stacey, P., Asselain, B. (1987). Is It Necessary to Irradiate the Breast After Conservative Surgery for Localized Cancer?. Arch Surg 122: 913-917 [Abstract]  
• Jewell, W. R., Krishnan, L., Reddy, E. K., Thomas, J. H., Mansfield, C. M. (1987). Intraoperative Implantation Radiation Therapy Plus Lumpectomy for Carcinoma of the Breast. Arch Surg 122: 687-690 [Abstract]  
• Miller, L. B., Steele, G., Cady, B., Wolfort, F. G., Bothe, A. Jr (1987). Resection of Tumors in Irradiated Fields With Subsequent Immediate Reconstruction. Arch Surg 122: 461-466 [Abstract]  
• Munoz, E., Shamash, F., Friedman, M., Teicher, I., Wise, L. (1986). Lumpectomy vs Mastectomy: The Costs of Breast Preservation for Cancer. Arch Surg 121: 1297-1301 [Abstract]  
• Hermann, R. E., Esselstyn, C. B. Jr, Crile, G. Jr, Cooperman, A. M., Antunez, A. R., Hoerr, S. O. (1985). Results of Conservative Operations for Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 120: 746-751 [Abstract]  
• Romsdahl, M. M., Montague, E. D., Ames, F. C., Richards, P. C., Schell, S. R. (1983). Conservation Surgery and Irradiation as Treatment for Early Breast Cancer. Arch Surg 118: 521-528 [Abstract]