In State T3 carcinoma of the larynx (carcinoma restricted to the vocal cords, causing complete immobility of the cords but not extending to adjacent structures), laryngectomy leads to a three-year survival rate of approximately 60 per cent and the loss of normal speech. Radiation therapy, on the other hand, leads to a lower survival (30 to 40 per cent at three years) but preserves normal or nearly normal speech. We investigated attitudes toward the quantity and quality of life in 37 healthy volunteers, interviewing 12 firefighters and 25 middle and upper management executives to determine their preferences for longevity and voice preservation. We used the principles of expected utility theory to develop a method for sharpening decisions involving tradeoffs between quantity and quality of life. Our analysis indicates that to maintain their voices, approximately 20 per cent of volunteers would choose radiation instead of surgery. These results suggest that treatment choices should be made on the basis of patients' attitudes toward the quality as well as the quantity of survival.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Starmer, H. M., Ishman, S. L., Flint, P. W., Bhatti, N. I., Richmon, J., Koch, W., Webster, K., Tufano, R., Gourin, C. G.
(2009). Complications That Affect Postlaryngectomy Voice Restoration: Primary Surgery vs Salvage Surgery. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
135: 1165-1169
[Abstract][Full Text]
Salz, T., Brewer, N. T.
(2009). Offering Chemotherapy and Hospice Jointly: One Solution to Hospice Underuse. Med Decis Making
29: 521-531
[Abstract]
Vartanian, J. G., Kowalski, L. P.
(2009). Acceptance of Major Surgical Procedures and Quality of Life Among Long-term Survivors of Advanced Head and Neck Cancer. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
135: 376-379
[Abstract][Full Text]
Meadowcroft, J.
(2008). Patients, Politics, and Power: Government Failure and the Politicization of U.K. Health Care. J Med Philos
33: 427-444
[Abstract][Full Text]
van der Pol, M., Shiell, A.
(2007). Extrinsic Goals and Time Tradeoff. Med Decis Making
27: 406-413
[Abstract]
Wise, R. A.
(2007). Ethical Issues Confronted In Pulmonary Clinical Trials. Proc Am Thorac Soc
4: 200-205
[Abstract][Full Text]
Weinfurt, K. P.
(2007). Value of High-Cost Cancer Care: A Behavioral Science Perspective. JCO
25: 223-227
[Abstract][Full Text]
Sanchez, J.-L. A., Pereperez, S. B., Bastida, J. L., Martinez, M. M.
(2007). Cost-Utility Analysis Applied to the Treatment of Burn Patients in a Specialized Center. Arch Surg
142: 50-57
[Abstract][Full Text]
Pfister, D. G., Laurie, S. A., Weinstein, G. S., Mendenhall, W. M., Adelstein, D. J., Ang, K. K., Clayman, G. L., Fisher, S. G., Forastiere, A. A., Harrison, L. B., Lefebvre, J.-L., Leupold, N., List, M. A., O'Malley, B. O., Patel, S., Posner, M. R., Schwartz, M. A., Wolf, G. T.
(2006). American Society of Clinical Oncology Clinical Practice Guideline for the Use of Larynx-Preservation Strategies in the Treatment of Laryngeal Cancer. JCO
24: 3693-3704
[Abstract][Full Text]
Pfister, D. G., Ridge, J. A.
(2006). Induction Chemotherapy for Larynx Preservation: Patient Selection or Therapeutic Effect?. JCO
24: 540-543
[Full Text]
Tsuchiya, A., Dolan, P.
(2005). The QALY Model and Individual Preferences for Health States and Health Profiles over Time: A Systematic Review of the Literature. Med Decis Making
25: 460-467
[Abstract]
Wakker, P. P., Jansen, S. J. T., Stiggelbout, A. M.
(2004). Anchor Levels as a New Tool for the Theory and Measurement of Multiattribute Utility. Decision Analysis
1: 217-234
[Abstract]
Mandelblatt, J., Armetta, C., Yabroff, K. R., Liang, W., Lawrence, W.
(2004). Descriptive Review of the Literature on Breast Cancer Outcomes: 1990 Through 2000. J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr
2004: 8-44
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hanna, E., Sherman, A., Cash, D., Adams, D., Vural, E., Fan, C.-Y., Suen, J. Y.
(2004). Quality of Life for Patients Following Total Laryngectomy vs Chemoradiation for Laryngeal Preservation. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
130: 875-879
[Abstract][Full Text]
Fairclough, D. L
(2004). Patient reported outcomes as endpoints in medical research. Stat Methods Med Res
13: 115-138
[Abstract]
Groome, P. A., O'Sullivan, B., Irish, J. C., Rothwell, D. M., Schulze, K., Warde, P. R., Schneider, K. M., Mackenzie, R. G., Hodson, D. I., Hammond, J. A., Gulavita, S. P.P., Eapen, L. J., Dixon, P. F., Bissett, R. J., Mackillop, W. J.
(2003). Management and Outcome Differences in Supraglottic Cancer Between Ontario, Canada, and the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Areas of the United States. JCO
21: 496-505
[Abstract][Full Text]
Cardoso, F., Di Leo, A., Lohrisch, C., Bernard, C., Ferreira, F., Piccart, M. J.
(2002). Second and subsequent lines of chemotherapy for metastatic breast cancer: what did we learn in the last two decades?. Ann Oncol
13: 197-207
[Abstract][Full Text]
Simes, R. J., Coates, A. S.
(2001). Patient Preferences for Adjuvant Chemotherapy of Early Breast Cancer: How Much Benefit Is Needed?. J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr
2001: 146-152
[Abstract][Full Text]
Unic, I., Verhoef, L. C.G., Stalmeier, P. F.M., Van Daal, W. A.J.
(2000). Prophylactic Mastectomy or Screening in Women Suspected to Have the BRCA1/2 Mutation: A Prospective Pilot Study of Women's Treatment Choices and Medical and Decision-analytic Recommendations. Med Decis Making
20: 251-262
[Abstract]
Morreim, E. H.
(2000). Quality of Life: Erosions and Opportunities Under Managed Care. J Law Med Ethics
28: 144-158
List, M. A., Stracks, J., Colangelo, L., Butler, P., Ganzenko, N., Lundy, D., Sullivan, P., Haraf, D., Kies, M., Goodwin, W., Vokes, E. E.
(2000). How Do Head and Neck Cancer Patients Prioritize Treatment Outcomes Before Initiating Treatment?. JCO
18: 877-877
[Abstract][Full Text]
Eisenberg, J. M.
(1999). Ten Lessons for Evidence-Based Technology Assessment. JAMA
282: 1865-1869
[Full Text]
Goodwin, J. S.
(1999). Geriatrics and the Limits of Modern Medicine. NEJM
340: 1283-1285
[Full Text]
Terrell, J. E., Fisher, S. G., Wolf, G. T., for the Veterans Affairs Laryngeal Cancer Study Gr,
(1998). Long-term Quality of Life After Treatment of Laryngeal Cancer. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
124: 964-971
[Abstract][Full Text]
Brundage, M. D., Davidson, J. R., Mackillop, W. J., Feldman-Stewart, D., Groome, P.
(1998). Using a Treatment-tradeoff Method to Elicit Preferences for the Treatment of Locally Advanced Non-Small-cell Lung Cancer. Med Decis Making
18: 256-267
[Abstract]
Unic, I., Stalmeier, P. F.M., Verhoef, L. C.G., Van Daal, W. A.J.
(1998). Assessment of the Time-tradeoff Val ues for Prophylactic Mastectomy of Women with a Suspected Genetic Predisposition to Breast Cancer. Med Decis Making
18: 268-277
[Abstract]
Gage, B. F., Cardinalli, A. B., Owens, D. K.
(1998). Cost-Effectiveness of Preference-Based Antithrombotic Therapy for Patients With Nonvalvular Atrial Fibrillation. Stroke
29: 1083-1091
[Abstract][Full Text]
Stewart, M. G., Chen, A. Y., Stach, C. B.
(1998). Outcomes Analysis of Voice and Quality of Life in Patients With Laryngeal Cancer. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
124: 143-148
[Abstract][Full Text]
Prager, T. C., Urso, R. G., Ruiz, R. S.
(1997). Cataract Extraction Rates and Insurance Status. JAMA
278: 1489-1490
[Abstract]
Nease, R. F. JR, Owens, D. K.
(1997). Use of Influence Diagrams to Structure Medical Decisions. Med Decis Making
17: 263-275
[Abstract]
Roest, F. H.J., Eijkemans, M. J.C., Van Der Donk, J., Levendag, P. C., Meeuwis, C. A., Schmitz, P. I.M., Habbema, J. D. F.
(1997). The Use of Confidence Intervals for Individual Utilities:: Limits to Formal Decision Analysis for Treatment Choice. Med Decis Making
17: 285-291
[Abstract]
Cher, D. J., Miyamoto, J., Lenert, L. A.
(1997). Incorporating Risk Attitude into Markov-process Decision Models:: Importance for Individual Decision Making. Med Decis Making
17: 340-350
[Abstract]
Szabo, E., Moody, H., Hamilton, T., Ang, C., Kovithavongs, C., Kjellstrand, C.
(1997). Choice of Treatment Improves Quality of Life: A Study on Patients Undergoing Dialysis. Arch Intern Med
157: 1352-1356
[Abstract]
Bleichrodt, H., Johannesson, M.
(1997). The Validity of QALYs: An Experimental Test of Constant Proportional Tradeoff and Utility Independence. Med Decis Making
17: 21-32
[Abstract]
Gage, B. F., Cardinalli, A. B., Owens, D. K.
(1996). The Effect of Stroke and Stroke Prophylaxis With Aspirin or Warfarin on Quality of Life. Arch Intern Med
156: 1829-1836
[Abstract]
Stalmeier, P. F.M., Bezembinder, T. G.G., Unic, I. J.
(1996). Proportional Heuristics in Time Tradeoff and Conjoint Measurement. Med Decis Making
16: 36-44
[Abstract]
Wakker, P., Stiggelbout, A.
(1995). Explaining Distortions in Utility Elicitation through the Rank-dependent Model for Risky Choices. Med Decis Making
15: 180-186
[Abstract]
Goldstein, M. K., Clarke, A. E., Michelson, D., Garber, A. M., Bergen, M. R., Lenert, L. A.
(1994). Developing and Testing a Multimedia Presentation of a Health-state Description. Med Decis Making
14: 336-344
[Abstract]
Nease, R. F., Owens, D. K.
(1994). A Method for Estimating the Cost- Effectiveness of Incorporating Patient Preferences into Practice Guidelines. Med Decis Making
14: 382-392
[Abstract]
Nease, R. F.
(1994). Risk Attitudes in Gambles Involving Length of Life: Aspirations, Variations, and Ruminations. Med Decis Making
14: 201-203
Stiggelbout, A.M., Kiebert, G.M., Kievit, J., Leer, J.W.H., Stoter, G., De Haes, J.C.J.M.
(1994). Utility Assessment in Cancer Patients: Adjustment of Time Tradeoff Scores for the Utility of Life Years and Comparison with Standard Gamble Scores. Med Decis Making
14: 82-90
[Abstract]
Johannesson, M., Pliskin, J. S., Weinstein, M. C.
(1993). Are Healthy-years Equivalents an Improvement over Quality-adjusted Life Years?. Med Decis Making
13: 281-286
[Abstract]
Redelmeier, D. A., Lorig, K.
(1993). Assessing the Clinical Importance of Symptomatic Improvements: An Illustration in Rheumatology. Arch Intern Med
153: 1337-1342
[Abstract]
Kiebert, G. M., Stiggelbout, A. M., Leer, J.-W. H., Kievit, J., De Haes, H. J.C.J.M.
(1993). Test-Retest Reliabilities of Two Treatment-preference Instruments in Measuring Utilities. Med Decis Making
13: 133-140
[Abstract]
Tsevat, J., Goldman, L., Soukup, J. R., Lamas, G. A., Connors, K. F., Chapin, C. C., Lee, T. H.
(1993). Stability of Time-tradeoff Utilities in Survivors of Myocardial Infarction. Med Decis Making
13: 161-165
[Abstract]
Mendelsohn, M., Morris, M., Gallagher, R.
(1993). A Comparative Study of Speech After Total Laryngectomy and Total Laryngopharyngectomy. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
119: 508-510
[Abstract]
Vokes, E. E., Weichselbaum, R. R., Lippman, S. M., Hong, W. K.
(1993). Head and Neck Cancer. NEJM
328: 184-194
[Full Text]
Maas, A., Stalpers, L.
(1992). Assessing Utilities by Means of Conjoint Measurement: An Application in Medical Decision Analysis. Med Decis Making
12: 288-297
[Abstract]
Katz, D. A., Littenberg, B., Cronenwett, J. L.
(1992). Management of Small Abdominal Aortic Aneurysms: Early Surgery vs Watchful Waiting. JAMA
268: 2678-2686
[Abstract]
Hazen, G. B., Hopp, W. J., Pellissier, J. M.
(1991). Continuous-risk Utility Assessment in Medical Decision Making. Med Decis Making
11: 294-304
[Abstract]
Mehrez, A., Gafni, A.
(1991). The Healthy-years Equivalents: How to Measure Them Using the Standard Gamble Approach. Med Decis Making
11: 140-146
[Abstract]
Uhlmann, R. F., Pearlman, R. A.
(1991). Perceived Quality of Life and Preferences for Life-Sustaining Treatment in Older Adults. Arch Intern Med
151: 495-497
[Abstract]
Lindsey, P. A., Newhouse, J. P.
(1990). The Cost and Value of Second Surgical Opinion Programs: A Critical Review of the Literature. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
15: 543-570
[Abstract]
Dawson, N. V., Cebul, R. D.
(1990). Advances in Quantitative Techniques for Making Medical Decisions: The Last Decade. Eval Health Prof
13: 37-62
[Abstract]
Wachter, R. M., Luce, J. M., Hearst, N., Lo, B.
(1989). Decisions about Resuscitation: Inequities among Patients with Different Diseases but Similar Prognoses. ANN INTERN MED
111: 525-532
[Abstract]
Miller, R. J.
(1989). The football approach to treating cancer patients. AM J HOSP PALLIAT CARE
6: 13-14
Miller, R. J.
(1989). The role of chemotherapy in the hospice patient: A problem of definition. AM J HOSP PALLIAT CARE
6: 19-26
Koprowski, C. D., Longstreth, W. T. Jr, Cebul, R. D.
(1989). Clinical Neuroepidemiology: III. Decisions. Arch Neurol
46: 223-229
[Abstract]
Berwick, D. M.
(1988). Toward an Applied Technology for Quality Measurement in Health Care. Med Decis Making
8: 253-258
[Abstract]
Donabedian, A.
(1988). The Quality of Care: How Can It Be Assessed?. JAMA
260: 1743-1748
[Abstract]
Forrow, L., Wartman, S. A., Brock, D. W.
(1988). Science, Ethics, and the Making of Clinical Decisions: Implications for Risk Factor Intervention. JAMA
259: 3161-3167
[Abstract]
Krumins, P. E., Fihn, S. D., Kent, D. L.
(1988). Symptom Severity and Patients' Values in the Decision to Perform a Transurethral Resection of the Prostate. Med Decis Making
8: 1-8
[Abstract]
Matchar, D. B., Pauker, S. G.
(1987). Endarterectomy in Carotid Artery Disease: A Decision Analysis. JAMA
258: 793-798
[Abstract]
KASSIRER, J. P., MOSKOWITZ, A. J., LAU, J., PAUKER, S. G.
(1987). Decision Analysis: A Progress Report. ANN INTERN MED
106: 275-291
[Abstract]
Twycross, R. G
(1987). Quality before quantity - a note of caution. Palliat Med
1: 65-72
[Abstract]
Detsky, A. S., Mclaughlin, J. R., Abrams, H. B., Whittaker, J. S., Whitwell, J., L'Abbe, K., Jeejeebhoy, K. N.
(1986). A Cost-Utility Analysis of the Home Parenteral Nutrition Program at Toronto General Hospital: 1970-1982. JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr
10: 49-57
[Abstract]
Miyamoto, J. M., Eraker, S. A.
(1985). Parameter Estimates for a QALY Utility Model. Med Decis Making
5: 191-213
Christensen-Szalanski, J. J.J.
(1984). Discount Functions and the Measurement of Patients' Values: Women's Decisions During Childbirth. Med Decis Making
4: 47-58
Kottke, T. E., Feldman, R. D., Albert, D. A.
(1984). The Risk Ratio Is Insufficient for Clinical Decisions: The Case of Prophylactic Cholecystectomy. Med Decis Making
4: 177-194
Churchill, D.N., Lemon, B.C., Torrance, G.W.
(1984). A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis and Hospital Hemodialysis. Med Decis Making
4: 489-500
RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE,
(1983). Clinical Research Methods: An Annotated Bibliography. ANN INTERN MED
99: 419-424
[Abstract]
DONABEDIAN, A.
(1983). Quality, Cost, and Clinical Decisions. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
468: 196-204
[Abstract]
Evans, R. W.
(1983). Health Care Technology and the Inevitability of Resource Allocation and Rationing Decisions: Part II. JAMA
249: 2208-2219
[Abstract]
ERAKER, S. A., POLITSER, P.
(1982). How Decisions are Reached: Physician and Patient. ANN INTERN MED
97: 262-268
[Abstract]
Bursztajn, H., Hamm, R. M.
(1982). The Clinical Utility of Utility Assessment. Med Decis Making
2: 161-165
Sutherland, H. J., Llewellyn-Thomas, H., Boyd, N. F., Till, J. E.
(1982). Attitudes Toward Quality of Survival: The Concept of "Maximal Endurable Time". Med Decis Making
2: 299-309
[Abstract]
Previous
