We examined the incidence of seven common surgical procedures in seven hospital service areas in southern Norway, in 21 districts in the West Midlands of the United Kingdom, and in the 18 most heavily populated hospital service areas in Vermont, Maine, and Rhode Island. Although surgical rates were higher in the New England states than in the United Kingdom or Norway, there was no greater degree of variability in the rates of surgery among the service areas within the three New England states. Hernia repair was more variable in England (P less than 0.05) and hysterectomy in Norway (P less than 0.05) than in the other countries. There was consistency among countries in the rank order of variability for most procedures: tonsillectomy, hemorrhoidectomy, hysterectomy, and prostatectomy varied more from area to area than did appendectomy, hernia repair, or cholecystectomy. The degree of variation generally appeared to be more characteristic of the procedure than of the country in which it was performed. Thus, differences among countries in the methods of organizing and financing care appear to have little relation to the intrinsic variability in the incidence of common surgical procedures among hospital service areas in these countries. Despite the differences in average rates of use, the degrees of controversy and uncertainty concerning the indications for these procedures seem to be similar among clinicians in all three countries.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Lilford, R. J
(2009). Should the NHS strive to eradicate all unexplained variation? No. BMJ
339: b4809-b4809
[Full Text]
Mulley, A. G
(2009). Inconvenient truths about supplier induced demand and unwarranted variation in medical practice. BMJ
339: b4073-b4073
[Full Text]
Rovers, M. M., Hoes, A. W., Klinkhamer, S., Schilder, A. G. M.
(2009). Influence of Single-Trial Results on Clinical Practice: Example of Adenotonsillectomy in Children. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
135: 970-975
[Abstract][Full Text]
Merry, A. F
(2009). How does the law recognize and deal with medical errors?. JRSM
102: 265-271
[Full Text]
McPherson, K.
(2008). Commentary: James Alison Glover (1874-1963), OBE (1919) CBE (1941) MD (1905) DPH (1905) FRCP (1933): health care variations research then and now. Int J Epidemiol
37: 19-23
[Full Text]
Rochon, P. A., Stukel, T. A., Bronskill, S. E., Gomes, T., Sykora, K., Wodchis, W. P., Hillmer, M., Kopp, A., Gurwitz, J. H., Anderson, G. M.
(2007). Variation in Nursing Home Antipsychotic Prescribing Rates. Arch Intern Med
167: 676-683
[Abstract][Full Text]
Lopushinsky, S. R., Austin, P. C., Rabeneck, L., Kulkarni, G. S., Urbach, D. R.
(2007). Regional Variation in Surgery for Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease in Ontario. SURG INNOV
14: 35-40
[Abstract]
Govindarajan, A., Coburn, N. G., Kiss, A., Rabeneck, L., Smith, A. J., Law, C. H. L.
(2006). Population-based assessment of the surgical management of locally advanced colorectal cancer.. JNCI J Natl Cancer Inst
98: 1474-1481
[Abstract][Full Text]
HOBBY, J. L., DIAS, J. J.
(2006). A review of Hand Surgery Provision in England.. J Hand Surg Eur Vol
31: 230-235
[Abstract][Full Text]
Lougheed, M. D., Garvey, N., Chapman, K. R., Cicutto, L., Dales, R., Day, A. G., Hopman, W. M., Lam, M., Sears, M. R., Szpiro, K., To, T., Paterson, N. A.M., for the Ontario Respiratory Outcomes Research Netw,
(2006). The Ontario Asthma Regional Variation Study: emergency department visit rates and the relation to hospitalization rates.. Chest
129: 909-917
[Abstract][Full Text]
Krupski, T. L., Kwan, L., Afifi, A. A., Litwin, M. S.
(2005). Geographic and Socioeconomic Variation in the Treatment of Prostate Cancer. JCO
23: 7881-7888
[Abstract][Full Text]
Dunn, W. R., Schackman, B. R., Walsh, C., Lyman, S., Jones, E. C., Warren, R. F., Marx, R. G.
(2005). Variation in Orthopaedic Surgeons' Perceptions About the Indications for Rotator Cuff Surgery. JBJS
87: 1978-1984
[Abstract][Full Text]
To, T., Wajja, A., Wales, P. W., Langer, J. C.
(2005). Population Demographic Indicators Associated With Incidence of Pyloric Stenosis. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
159: 520-525
[Abstract][Full Text]
Randolph, G., Fried, B., Loeding, L., Margolis, P., Lannon, C.
(2005). Organizational Characteristics and Preventive Service Delivery in Private Practices: A Peek Inside the "Black Box" of Private Practices Caring for Children. Pediatrics
115: 1704-1711
[Abstract][Full Text]
Aujesky, D. A., Cornuz, J., Bosson, J.-L., Bounameaux, H., Emmerich, J., Hull, R. D., Mackay, E., Perrier, A., Quan, H., Tsuyuki, R. T., Ghali, W. A.
(2004). Uptake of new treatment strategies for deep vein thrombosis: an international audit. Int J Qual Health Care
16: 193-200
[Abstract][Full Text]
Skinner, J. S
(2004). Use of healthcare resources in the last six months of life: Author's reply. BMJ
328: 1202-1202
[Full Text]
Kocevar, V. S., Bisgaard, H., Jonsson, L., Valovirta, E., Kristensen, F., Yin, D. D., Thomas, J. III
(2004). Variations in Pediatric Asthma Hospitalization Rates and Costs Between and Within Nordic Countries. Chest
125: 1680-1684
[Abstract][Full Text]
To, T., Williams, J I., Wu, K., Theriault, M.-E., Goel, V.
(2003). Comparison of methods to identify outliers observed in health services small area variation studies. Stat Methods Med Res
12: 531-546
[Abstract]
Maynard, A., Bloor, K.
(2003). Trust and performance management in the medical marketplace. JRSM
96: 532-539
[Full Text]
HOWLEY, P. P., GIBBERD, R.
(2003). Using hierarchical models to analyse clinical indicators: a comparison of the gamma-Poisson and beta-binomial models. Int J Qual Health Care
15: 319-329
[Abstract][Full Text]
Forrest, C. B., Majeed, A., Weiner, J. P., Carroll, K., Bindman, A. B.
(2003). Referral of Children to Specialists in the United States and the United Kingdom. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
157: 279-285
[Abstract][Full Text]
Groome, P. A., O'Sullivan, B., Irish, J. C., Rothwell, D. M., Schulze, K., Warde, P. R., Schneider, K. M., Mackenzie, R. G., Hodson, D. I., Hammond, J. A., Gulavita, S. P.P., Eapen, L. J., Dixon, P. F., Bissett, R. J., Mackillop, W. J.
(2003). Management and Outcome Differences in Supraglottic Cancer Between Ontario, Canada, and the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Areas of the United States. JCO
21: 496-505
[Abstract][Full Text]
Newhouse, J. P.
(2002). Why Is There A Quality Chasm?. Health Aff (Millwood)
21: 13-25
[Abstract][Full Text]
Girard, F., Guillemin, F., Novella, J. L., Valckenaere, I., Krzanowska, K., Vitry, F., Vittecoq, O., Eschard, J. P., Blanchard, F., Le Loet, X.
(2002). Health-care use by rheumatoid arthritis patients compared with non-arthritic subjects. Rheumatology (Oxford)
41: 167-175
[Abstract][Full Text]
Quintana, J M, Cabriada, J, Lopez de Tejada, I, Varona, M, Oribe, V, Barrios, B, Arostegui, I, Bilbao, A
(2002). Development of explicit criteria for cholecystectomy. Qual Saf Health Care
11: 320-326
[Abstract][Full Text]
Wai, E. K., Kreder, H. J., Williams, J. I.
(2002). Arthroscopic Debridement of the Knee for Osteoarthritis in Patients Fifty Years of Age or Older : Utilization and Outcomes in the Province of Ontario. JBJS
84: 17-22
[Abstract][Full Text]
Coyte, P. C., Croxford, R., Asche, C. V., To, T., Feldman, W., Friedberg, J.
(2001). Physician and Population Determinants of Rates of Middle-Ear Surgery in Ontario. JAMA
286: 2128-2135
[Abstract][Full Text]
Lichtenberg, F. R.
(2001). Are The Benefits Of Newer Drugs Worth Their Cost? Evidence From The 1996 MEPS. Health Aff (Millwood)
20: 241-251
[Abstract][Full Text]
Maynard, A.
(2001). Ethics and health care 'underfunding'. J. Med. Ethics
27: 223-227
[Abstract][Full Text]
Culyer, A. J
(2001). Equity - some theory and its policy implications. J. Med. Ethics
27: 275-283
[Abstract][Full Text]
Herndon, J. H., Davidson, S. M., Apazidis, A.
(2001). Recent Socioeconomic Trends in Orthopaedic Practice. JBJS
83: 1097-1105
[Full Text]
Wrobel, J. S., Mayfield, J. A., Reiber, G. E.
(2001). Geographic Variation of Lower-Extremity Major Amputation in Individuals With and Without Diabetes in the Medicare Population. Diabetes Care
24: 860-864
[Abstract][Full Text]
Stewart, M. G., Friedman, E. M., Sulek, M., deJong, A., Hulka, G. F., Bautista, M. H., Anderson, S. E.
(2001). Validation of an Outcomes Instrument for Tonsil and Adenoid Disease. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
127: 29-35
[Abstract][Full Text]
Mattila, P. S., Tahkokallio, O., Tarkkanen, J., Pitkaniemi, J., Karvonen, M., Tuomilehto, J.
(2001). Causes of Tonsillar Disease and Frequency of Tonsillectomy Operations. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
127: 37-44
[Abstract][Full Text]
Jaglal, S. B., McIsaac, W. J., Hawker, G., Jaakkimainen, L., Cadarette, S. M., Chan, B. T.B.
(2000). Patterns of use of the bone mineral density test in Ontario, 1992-1998. CMAJ
163: 1139-1143
[Abstract][Full Text]
Schneider, E. C., Riehl, V., Courte-Wienecke, S., Eddy, D. M., Sennett, C.
(1999). Enhancing Performance Measurement: NCQA's Road Map for a Health Information Framework. JAMA
282: 1184-1190
[Abstract][Full Text]
Weel, A. E. A. M., Uitterlinden, A. G., Westendorp, I. C. D., Burger, H., Schuit, S. C. E., Hofman, A., Helmerhorst, T. J. M., van Leeuwen, J. P. T. M., Pols, H. A. P.
(1999). Estrogen Receptor Polymorphism Predicts the Onset of Natural and Surgical Menopause. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab.
84: 3146-3150
[Abstract][Full Text]
Coyte, P. C., Young, W.
(1999). Regional variations in the use of home care services in Ontario, 1993/95. CMAJ
161: 376-380
[Abstract][Full Text]
VITALE, M. G., KRANT, J. J., GELIJNS, A. C., HEITJAN, D. F., ARONS, R. R., BIGLIANI, L. U., FLATOW, E. L.
(1999). Geographic Variations in the Rates of Operative Procedures Involving the Shoulder, Including Total Shoulder Replacement, Humeral Head Replacement, and Rotator Cuff Repair. JBJS
81: 763-72
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ashton, C. M., Petersen, N. J., Souchek, J., Menke, T. J., Yu, H.-J., Pietz, K., Eigenbrodt, M. L., Barbour, G., Kizer, K. W., Wray, N. P.
(1999). Geographic Variations in Utilization Rates in Veterans Affairs Hospitals and Clinics. NEJM
340: 32-39
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rich, E. C., Kralewski, J., Feldman, R., Dowd, B., Bernhardt, T. S.
(1998). Variations in the Management of Primary Care: Effect on Cost in an HMO Network. Arch Intern Med
158: 2363-2371
[Abstract][Full Text]
Duggan, A E, Usmani, I, Neal, K R, Logan, R F A
(1998). Appendicectomy, childhood hygiene, Helicobacter pylori status, and risk of inflammatory bowel disease: a case control study. Gut
43: 494-498
[Abstract][Full Text]
Deleyiannis, F. W.-B., Weymuller, E. A. Jr, Garcia, I., Potosky, A. L.
(1997). Geographic Variation in the Utilization of Esophagoscopy and Bronchoscopy in Head and Neck Cancer. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
123: 1203-1210
[Abstract]
Kane, R. L.
(1997). Commentary. Med Care Res Rev
54: 321-325
Van Miltenburg-Van Zijl, A. J.M., Bossuyt, P. M.M., Nette, R. W., Simoons, M. L., Taylor, T. R.
(1997). Cardiologists' Use of Clinical Information for Management Decisions for Patients with Unstable Angina:: A Policy Analysis. Med Decis Making
17: 292-297
[Abstract]
Chertow, G. M.
(1996). Grafts vs Fistulas for Hemodialysis Patients: Equal Access for All?. JAMA
276: 1343-1344
[Abstract]
Brook, R. H., Kamberg, C. J., McGlynn, E. A.
(1996). Health System Reform and Quality. JAMA
276: 476-480
[Abstract]
Llewellyn-Thomas, H. A., Williams, J. I., Levy, L., Naylor, C.D.
(1996). Using a Trade-off Technique to Assess Patients' Treatment Preferences for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia. Med Decis Making
16: 262-272
[Abstract]
Arndt, M., Bradbury, R. C., Golec, J.
(1995). Indications for Hysterectomy: Variation within and Across Hospitals. Med Care Res Rev
52: 342-363
[Abstract]
Elliott, P., Martuzzi, M., Shaddick, G.
(1995). Spatial statistical methods in environmental epidemiology: a critique. Stat Methods Med Res
4: 137-159
[Abstract]
Langland-Orban, B., Greene, B. R., Vogel, W. B.
(1995). Graduate Education in Health Services Administration: Integrating Business with Clinical Perspectives. Eval Health Prof
18: 217-228
[Abstract]
Weiner, J. P., Parente, S. T., Garnick, D. W., Fowles, J., Lawthers, A. G., Palmer, R. H.
(1995). Variation in Office-Based Quality: A Claims-Based Profile of Care Provided to Medicare Patients With Diabetes. JAMA
273: 1503-1508
[Abstract]
Delamothe, T
(1994). Using outcomes research in clinical practice. BMJ
308: 1583-1584
[Full Text]
Tamblyn, R.
(1994). Is the Public being Protected? Prevention of Suboptimalmedical Practice Through Training Programs and Credentialing Examinations. Eval Health Prof
17: 198-221
[Abstract]
Keskimaki, I., Aro, S., Teperi, J.
(1994). Regional variation in surgical procedure rates in Finland. Scand J Public Health
22: 132-138
[Abstract]
Mirvis, D. N.
(1994). Health System Reform: A Provider or a Patient Perspective?. Arch Fam Med
3: 241-245
[Abstract]
Linsk, J. A.
(1993). American Medical Culture and the Health Care Crisis. American Journal of Medical Quality
8: 174-180
[Abstract]
Jacobsen, S. J., Guess, H. A., Panser, L., Girman, C. J., Chute, C. G., Oesterling, J. E., Lieber, M. M.
(1993). A Population-Based Study of Health Care^Seeking Behavior for Treatment of Urinary Symptoms: The Olmsted County Study of Urinary Symptoms and Health Status Among Men. Arch Fam Med
2: 729-735
[Abstract]
Lu-Yao, G. L., McLerran, D., Wasson, J., Wennberg, J. E., Prostate Patient Outcomes Research Team, , Wennberg, J. E., Wasson, J. H., Bubolz, T., Lindsay, C. C., Littenberg, B., Flood, A. B., Lu-Yao, G. L., Chang, C.-H., Mulley, A. G., Barry, M. J., Coley, C., Fowler, F. J., Bruskewitz, R., Albertson, P. C., Fleming, C.
(1993). An Assessment of Radical Prostatectomy: Time Trends, Geographic Variation, and Outcomes. JAMA
269: 2633-2636
[Abstract]
Carlson, K. J., Nichols, D. H., Schiff, I.
(1993). Indications for Hysterectomy. NEJM
328: 856-860
[Full Text]
Goldberg, K. C., Hartz, A. J., Jacobsen, S. J., Krakauer, H., Rimm, A. A.
(1992). Racial and Community Factors Influencing Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery Rates for All 1986 Medicare Patients. JAMA
267: 1473-1477
[Abstract]
Goodnough, L. T., Johnston, M. F. M., Toy, P. T. C. Y.
(1991). The Variability of Transfusion Practice in Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery. JAMA
265: 86-90
[Abstract]
Folland, S., Stano, M.
(1990). Small Area Variations: A Critical Review of Propositions, Methods, and Evidence. Med Care Res Rev
47: 419-465
De Alessi, L.
(1989). The Effect of Institutions on the Choices of Consumers and Providers of Health Care. Journal of Theoretical Politics
1: 427-458
[Abstract]
Knesper, D. J., Belcher, B. E., Cross, J. G.
(1989). A Market Analysis Comparing the Practices of Psychiatrists and Psychologists. Arch Gen Psychiatry
46: 305-314
[Abstract]
Laird, N. M., Louis, T. A.
(1989). Empirical Bayes Ranking Methods. JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL AND BEHAVIORAL STATISTICS
14: 29-46
[Abstract]
Barry, M. J., Mulley, A. G. Jr, Fowler, F. J., Wennberg, J. W.
(1988). Watchful Waiting vs Immediate Transurethral Resection for Symptomatic Prostatism: The Importance of Patients' Preferences. JAMA
259: 3010-3017
[Abstract]
Fowler, F. J. Jr, Wennberg, J. E., Timothy, R. P., Barry, M. J., Mulley, A. G. Jr, Hanley, D.
(1988). Symptom Status and Quality of Life Following Prostatectomy. JAMA
259: 3018-3022
[Abstract]
Menken, M., Hopkins, A., DeFriese, G. H.
(1988). Norms of Care in British and American Neurologic Practice. Arch Neurol
45: 94-98
[Abstract]
Chassin, M. R., Kosecoff, J., Park, R.E., Winslow, C. M., Kahn, K. L., Merrick, N. J., Keesey, J., Fink, A., Solomon, D. H., Brook, R. H.
(1987). Does Inappropriate Use Explain Geographic Variations in the Use of Health Care Services? A Study of Three Procedures. JAMA
258: 2533-2537
[Abstract]
Resnick, N. M., Yalla, S. V.
(1987). Detrusor Hyperactivity With Impaired Contractile Function: An Unrecognized but Common Cause of Incontinence in Elderly Patients. JAMA
257: 3076-3081
[Abstract]
Starfield, B.
(1987). Health Care Delivery. Topics in Early Childhood Special Education
6: 12-24
[Abstract]
Rutkow, I. M.
(1986). Ear, Nose, and Throat Operations in the United States, 1979 to 1984. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
112: 873-876
[Abstract]
Barnes, B. A., O'Brien, E., Comstock, C., D'Arpa, D. G., Donahue, C. L.
(1985). Report on Variation in Rates of Utilization of Surgical Services in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. JAMA
254: 371-375
[Abstract]
Luft, H. S.
(1983). Variations in Clinical Practice Patterns. Arch Intern Med
143: 1861-1862
[Abstract]
Hlatky, M. A., Lee, K. L., Botvinick, E. H., Brundage, B. H.
(1983). Diagnostic Test Use in Different Practice Settings: A Controlled Comparison. Arch Intern Med
143: 1886-1889
[Abstract]
Previous
