Does free medical care lead to better health than insurance plans that require the patient to shoulder part of the cost? In an effort to answer this question, we studied 3958 people between the ages of 14 and 61 who were free of disability that precluded work and had been randomly assigned to a set of insurance plans for three or five years. One plan provided free care; the others required enrollees to pay a share of their medical bills. As previously reported, patients in the latter group made approximately one-third fewer visits to a physician and were hospitalized about one-third less often. For persons with poor vision and for low-income persons with high blood pressure, free care brought an improvement (vision better by 0.2 Snellen lines, diastolic blood pressure lower by 3 mm Hg); better control of blood pressure reduced the calculated risk of early death among those at high risk. For the average participant, as well as for subgroups differing in income and initial health status, no significant effects were detected on eight other measures of health status and health habits. Confidence intervals for these eight measures were sufficiently narrow to rule out all but a minimal influence, favorable or adverse, of free care for the average participant. For some measures of health in subgroups of the population, however, the broader confidence intervals make this conclusion less certain.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Rubenfire, M., Lippo, G., Bodini, B. D., Blasi, F., Allegra, L., Bossone, E.
(2009). Evaluating Health-Related Quality of Life, Work Ability, and Disability in Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension: An Unmet Need. Chest
136: 597-603
[Abstract][Full Text]
Brook, R. H.
(2009). The Science of Health Care Reform. JAMA
301: 2486-2487
[Full Text]
Ross, J. S., Gross, C. P.
(2009). Policy Research: Using Evidence to Improve Healthcare Delivery Systems. Circulation
119: 891-898
[Full Text]
Burdick, J.
(2008). Moral Hazard and Health Care for All. Arch Surg
143: 931-932
[Full Text]
Wells, D. A., Ross, J. S., Detsky, A. S.
(2007). What Is Different About the Market for Health Care?. JAMA
298: 2785-2787
[Full Text]
Orszag, P. R., Ellis, P.
(2007). The Challenge of Rising Health Care Costs -- A View from the Congressional Budget Office. NEJM
357: 1793-1795
[Full Text]
Nyman, J. A.
(2007). American Health Policy: Cracks in the Foundation. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
32: 759-783
[Abstract]
DiMassa, G., Escarce, J. J.
(2007). Insurance and Health Care Expenditures: What's the Real Question?. ANN INTERN MED
146: 814-815
[Full Text]
Ingels, C., Debaveye, Y., Milants, I., Buelens, E., Peeraer, A., Devriendt, Y., Vanhoutte, T., Van Damme, A., Schetz, M., Wouters, P. J., Van den Berghe, G.
(2006). Strict blood glucose control with insulin during intensive care after cardiac surgery: impact on 4-years survival, dependency on medical care, and quality-of-life. Eur Heart J
27: 2716-2724
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rosenthal, M., Daniels, N.
(2006). Beyond Competition: The Normative Implications of Consumer-Driven Health Plans. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
31: 671-685
[Abstract]
Seid, M., McGlynn, E. A.
(2006). Funding for Biomedical Research. JAMA
295: 1000-1000
[Full Text]
Rosenthal, M., Hsuan, C., Milstein, A.
(2005). A Report Card On The Freshman Class Of Consumer-Directed Health Plans. Health Aff (Millwood)
24: 1592-1600
[Abstract][Full Text]
Myint, P. K., Luben, R. N., Surtees, P. G., Wainwright, N. W. J., Welch, A. A., Bingham, S. A., Wareham, N. J., Day, N. E., Khaw, K-T.
(2005). Respiratory function and self-reported functional health: EPIC-Norfolk population study. Eur Respir J
26: 494-502
[Abstract][Full Text]
Slade, E. P., Salkever, D. S., Rosenheck, R., Swanson, J., Swartz, M., Shern, D., Gallucci, G., Harding, C., Palmer, L., Russo, P.
(2005). Cost-Sharing Requirements and Access to Mental Health Care Among Medicare Enrollees With Schizophrenia. Psychiatr. Serv.
56: 960-966
[Abstract][Full Text]
Mohanty, S. A., Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U., Pati, S., Carrasquillo, O., Bor, D. H.
(2005). Health Care Expenditures of Immigrants in the United States: A Nationally Representative Analysis. AJPH
95: 1431-1438
[Abstract][Full Text]
Knickman, J. R.
(2005). When Health Policy Is the Problem. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
30: 367-374
Garber, A. M., Sox, H. C.
(2004). The U.S. Physician Workforce: Serious Questions Raised, Answers Needed. ANN INTERN MED
141: 732-734
[Full Text]
Newhouse, J. P.
(2004). Consumer-Directed Health Plans And The RAND Health Insurance Experiment. Health Aff (Millwood)
23: 107-113
[Abstract][Full Text]
McNeill, D.
(2004). Do Consumer-Directed Health Benefits Favor The Young And Healthy?. Health Aff (Millwood)
23: 186-193
[Abstract][Full Text]
Bindman, A. B., Haggstrom, D. A.
(2003). Small Steps or a Giant Leap for the Uninsured?. JAMA
290: 816-818
[Full Text]
Karter, A. J., Stevens, M. R., Herman, W. H., Ettner, S., Marrero, D. G., Safford, M. M., Engelgau, M. M., Curb, J. D., Brown, A. F.
(2003). Out-of-Pocket Costs and Diabetes Preventive Services: The Translating Research Into Action for Diabetes (TRIAD) study. Diabetes Care
26: 2294-2299
[Abstract][Full Text]
Silverstein, M., Sales, A. E., Koepsell, T. D.
(2003). Health Care Utilization and Expenditures Associated With Child Care Attendance: A Nationally Representative Sample. Pediatrics
111: e371-375
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rothman, R., Malone, R., Bryant, B., Horlen, C., Pignone, M.
(2003). Pharmacist Led, Primary Care-Based Disease Management Improves Hemoglobin Aic in High-Risk Patients With Diabetes. American Journal of Medical Quality
18: 51-58
[Abstract]
Adhikari, N., Sibbald, W.
(2003). The Large Cost of Critical Care: Realities and Challenges. Anesth. Analg.
96: 311-314
[Full Text]
Chen, A. Y., Chang, R.-K. R.
(2002). Factors Associated With Prescription Drug Expenditures Among Children: An Analysis of the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey. Pediatrics
109: 728-732
[Abstract][Full Text]
Guyatt, G. H., Osoba, D., Wu, A. W., Wyrwich, K. W., Norman, G. R., Clinical Significance Consensus Meeting Group,
(2002). Methods to Explain the Clinical Significance of Health Status Measures. Mayo Clin Proc.
77: 371-383
[Abstract]
Oliveria, S. A., Lapuerta, P., McCarthy, B. D., L'Italien, G. J., Berlowitz, D. R., Asch, S. M.
(2002). Physician-Related Barriers to the Effective Management of Uncontrolled Hypertension. Arch Intern Med
162: 413-420
[Abstract][Full Text]
Wong, M. D., Andersen, R., Sherbourne, C. D., Hays, R. D., Shapiro, M. F.
(2001). Effects of Cost Sharing on Care Seeking and Health Status: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. AJPH
91: 1889-1894
[Abstract][Full Text]
Bodenheimer, T. S.
(2001). Affordable Prescriptions for the Elderly. JAMA
286: 1762-1763
[Full Text]
Tamblyn, R., Laprise, R., Hanley, J. A., Abrahamowicz, M., Scott, S., Mayo, N., Hurley, J., Grad, R., Latimer, E., Perreault, R., McLeod, P., Huang, A., Larochelle, P., Mallet, L.
(2001). Adverse Events Associated With Prescription Drug Cost-Sharing Among Poor and Elderly Persons. JAMA
285: 421-429
[Abstract][Full Text]
Woodward, A., Kawachi, I.
(2000). Why reduce health inequalities?. J. Epidemiol. Community Health
54: 923-929
[Abstract][Full Text]
Oakley, A.
(2000). A Historical Perspective on the Use of Randomized Trials in Social Science Settings. Crime Delinquency
46: 315-329
[Abstract]
Doescher, M. P., Franks, P., Banthin, J. S., Clancy, C. M.
(2000). Supplemental Insurance and Mortality in Elderly Americans: Findings From a National Cohort. Arch Fam Med
9: 251-257
[Abstract][Full Text]
Lee, P. P.
(1999). Commentary on Caring for the Uninsured and Underinsured. Arch Ophthalmol
117: 392-393
[Full Text]
Kazis, L. E., Ren, X. S., Lee, A., Skinner, K., Rogers, W., Clark, J., Miller, D. R.
(1999). Health Status in VA Patients: Results from the Veterans Health Study. American Journal of Medical Quality
14: 28-38
[Abstract]
Testa, M. A., Lenderking, W. R.
(1999). The Impact of AIDS-Associated Wasting on Quality of Life: Qualitative Issues of Measurement and Evaluation. J. Nutr.
129: 282S-282S
[Full Text]
Ahlamaa-Tuompo, J., Linna, M., Kekomaki, M.
(1998). Impact of user charges and socio-economic environment on visits to paediatric trauma unit in Finland. Scand J Public Health
26: 265-269
[Abstract]
Martin, A. J., Stockler, M.
(1998). Quality-of-Life Assessment in Health Care Research and Practice. Eval Health Prof
21: 141-156
[Abstract]
Kazis, L. E., Miller, D. R., Clark, J., Skinner, K., Lee, A., Rogers, W., Spiro III, A., Payne, S., Fincke, G., Selim, A., Linzer, M.
(1998). Health-Related Quality of Life in Patients Served by the Department of Veterans Affairs: Results From the Veterans Health Study. Arch Intern Med
158: 626-632
[Abstract][Full Text]
Melhado, E. M.
(1998). Economists, Public Provision, and the Market: Changing Values in Policy Debate. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
23: 215-263
[Abstract]
Brook, R. H.
(1997). Managed Care Is Not the Problem, Quality Is. JAMA
278: 1612-1614
[Abstract]
Slater, C. H.
(1997). What Is Outcomes Research and What Can It Tell Us?. Eval Health Prof
20: 243-264
[Abstract]
Magid, D. J., Koepsell, T. D., Every, N. R., Martin, J. S., Siscovick, D. S., Wagner, E. H., Weaver, W. D.
(1997). Absence of Association between Insurance Copayments and Delays in Seeking Emergency Care among Patients with Myocardial Infarction. NEJM
336: 1722-1729
[Abstract][Full Text]
KANE, R. L.
(1996). Health Perceptions: Real and Imagined. American Behavioral Scientist
39: 707-716
[Abstract]
Testa, M. A., Simonson, D. C.
(1996). Assessment of Quality-of-Life Outcomes. NEJM
334: 835-840
[Full Text]
Selby, J. V., Fireman, B. H., Swain, B. E.
(1996). Effect of a Copayment on Use of the Emergency Department in a Health Maintenance Organization. NEJM
334: 635-642
[Abstract][Full Text]
Gunning-Schepers, L. J., Gepkens, A.
(1996). Reviews of interventions to reduce social inequalities in health: research and policy implications. Health Education Journal
55: 226-238
[Abstract]
Brandon, W. P.
(1995). A Large-Scale Social Science Experiment in Health Finance: Findings, Significance, and Value. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
20: 1051-1061
Fihn, S. D.
(1995). Physician Specialty, Systems of Health Care, and Patient Outcomes. JAMA
274: 1473-1474
[Abstract]
Rubin, R. J., Mendelson, D. N., Rasell, M. E.
(1995). Cost Sharing in Health Insurance. NEJM
333: 733-734
[Full Text]
Perneger, T. V., Whelton, P. K., Klag, M. J.
(1995). Race and End-Stage Renal Disease: Socioeconomic Status and Access to Health Care as Mediating Factors. Arch Intern Med
155: 1201-1208
[Abstract]
Rasell, M. E.
(1995). Cost Sharing in Health Insurance -- A Reexamination. NEJM
332: 1164-1168
[Full Text]
Grumbach, K., Bodenheimer, T.
(1995). Mechanisms for Controlling Costs. JAMA
273: 1223-1230
[Abstract]
Longo, D. R., Daugird, A. J.
(1994). Measuring the Quality of Care: Reforming the Health Care System. American Journal of Medical Quality
9: 104-115
[Abstract]
Braveman, P., Schaaf, V. M., Egerter, S., Bennett, T., Schecter, W.
(1994). Insurance-Related Differences in the Risk of Ruptured Appendix. NEJM
331: 444-449
[Abstract][Full Text]
Franks, P., Clancy, C. M., Gold, M. R.
(1993). Health Insurance and Mortality: Evidence From a National Cohort. JAMA
270: 737-741
[Abstract]
ADAY, L. A.
(1993). Equity, Accessibility, and Ethical Issues: Is the U.S. Health Care Reform Debate Asking the Right Questions?. American Behavioral Scientist
36: 724-740
[Abstract]
HAFNER-EATON, C.
(1993). Will the Phoenix Rise, and Where Should She Go?: The Women's Health Agenda. American Behavioral Scientist
36: 841-856
[Abstract]
Halpin Schauffler, H., Rodriguez, T.
(1993). Managed Care for Preventive Services: A Review of Policy Options. Med Care Res Rev
50: 153-198
Weissman, J. S., Gatsonis, C., Epstein, A. M.
(1992). Rates of Avoidable Hospitalization by Insurance Status in Massachusetts and Maryland. JAMA
268: 2388-2394
[Abstract]
Fisher, E., Welch, H. G., Wennberg, J. E.
(1992). Priorities in Oregon-Reply. JAMA
268: 1268-1268
[Abstract]
Rosenblatt, R. A.
(1992). Specialists or Generalists: On Whom Should We Base the American Health Care System?. JAMA
267: 1665-1666
[Abstract]
Udvarhelyi, I. S., Jennison, K., Phillips, R. S., Epstein, A. M.
(1991). Comparison of the Quality of Ambulatory Care for Fee-for-Service and Prepaid Patients. ANN INTERN MED
115: 394-400
[Abstract]
Brook, R. H.
(1991). Health, Health Insurance, and the Uninsured. JAMA
265: 2998-3002
[Abstract]
Grumbach, K., Bodenheimer, T., Himmelstein, D. U., Woolhandler, S.
(1991). Liberal Benefits, Conservative Spending: The Physicians for a National Health Program Proposal. JAMA
265: 2549-2554
[Abstract]
Moore, G. T.
(1991). Let's Provide Primary Care to All Uninsured Americans--Now!. JAMA
265: 2108-2109
[Abstract]
Brett, A., Grodin, M.
(1991). Ethical Aspects of Human Experimentation in Health Services Research. JAMA
265: 1854-1857
[Abstract]
Schoenberger, J. A., Testa, M., Ross, A. D., Brennan, W. K., Bannon, J. A.
(1990). Efficacy, Safety, and Quality-of-Life Assessment of Captopril Antihypertensive Therapy in Clinical Practice. Arch Intern Med
150: 301-306
[Abstract]
De Alessi, L.
(1989). The Effect of Institutions on the Choices of Consumers and Providers of Health Care. Journal of Theoretical Politics
1: 427-458
[Abstract]
Stewart, A. L., Greenfield, S., Hays, R. D., Wells, K., Rogers, W. H., Berry, S. D., McGlynn, E. A., Ware, J. E. Jr
(1989). Functional Status and Well-being of Patients With Chronic Conditions: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
262: 907-913
[Abstract]
Wells, K. B., Stewart, A., Hays, R. D., Burnam, M. A., Rogers, W., Daniels, M., Berry, S., Greenfield, S., Ware, J.
(1989). The Functioning and Well-being of Depressed Patients: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
262: 914-919
[Abstract]
Tarlov, A. R., Ware, J. E. Jr, Greenfield, S., Nelson, E. C., Perrin, E., Zubkoff, M.
(1989). The Medical Outcomes Study: An Application of Methods for Monitoring the Results of Medical Care. JAMA
262: 925-930
[Abstract]
Shapiro, M. F., Hayward, R. A., Freeman, H. E., Sudman, S., Corey, C. R.
(1989). Out-of-Pocket Payments and Use of Care for Serious and Minor Symptoms: Results of a National Survey. Arch Intern Med
149: 1645-1648
[Abstract]
Wells, K. B., Manning, W. G. Jr, Valdez, R. B.
(1989). The Effects of Insurance Generosity on the Psychological Distress and Psychological Well-being of a General Population. Arch Gen Psychiatry
46: 315-320
[Abstract]
Bodenheimer, T. S.
(1989). Payment Mechanisms under a National Health Program. Med Care Res Rev
46: 3-43
Mechanic, D.
(1989). Social Policy, Technology, and the Rationing of Health Care. Med Care Res Rev
46: 113-120
Broyles, R. W., Rosko, M. D.
(1988). The Demand for Health Insurance and Health Care: A Review of the Empirical Literature. Med Care Res Rev
45: 291-338
Brook, R. H., Lohr, K. N.
(1987). Monitoring Quality of Care in the Medicare Program: Two Proposed Systems. JAMA
258: 3138-3141
[Abstract]
Murata, P. J., Kane, R. L.
(1987). Do Families Get Family Care?. JAMA
257: 1912-1915
[Abstract]
HEALTH AND PUBLIC POLICY COMMITTEE,
(1987). Medicare Payment for Physician Services. ANN INTERN MED
106: 151-163
[Abstract]
Manning, W. G. Jr, Wells, K. B., Duan, N., Newhouse, J. P., Ware, J. E. Jr
(1986). How Cost Sharing Affects the Use of Ambulatory Mental Health Services. JAMA
256: 1930-1934
[Abstract]
MacKenzie, C. R., Charlson, M. E., DiGioia, D., Kelley, K.
(1986). A Patient-Specific Measure of Change in Maximal Function. Arch Intern Med
146: 1325-1329
[Abstract]
Fuchs, P. D.
(1986). Clinically and Statistically Significant Differences. JAMA
255: 1876-1876
[Abstract]
SHAPIRO, M. F., WARE, J. E. Jr, SHERBOURNE, C. D.
(1986). Effects of Cost Sharing on Seeking Care for Serious and Minor Symptoms: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial. ANN INTERN MED
104: 246-251
[Abstract]
Smith, G. R. Jr, Monson, R. A., Ray, D. C.
(1986). Patients With Multiple Unexplained Symptoms: Their Characteristics, Functional Health, and Health Care Utilization. Arch Intern Med
146: 69-72
[Abstract]
Keeler, E. B., Brook, R. H., Goldberg, G. A., Kamberg, C. J., Newhouse, J. P.
(1985). How Free Care Reduced Hypertension in the Health Insurance Experiment. JAMA
254: 1926-1931
[Abstract]
Previous
