Does a prepaid group practice deliver less care than the fee-for-service system when both serve comparable populations with comparable benefits? To answer this question, we randomly assigned a group of 1580 persons to receive care free of charge from either a fee-for-service physician of their choice (431 persons) or the Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound (1149 persons). In addition, 733 prior enrollees of the Cooperative were studied as a control group. The rate of hospital admissions in both groups at the Cooperative was about 40 per cent less than in the fee-for-service group (P less than 0.01), although ambulatory-visit rates were similar. The calculated expenditure rate for all services was about 25 per cent less in the two Cooperative groups (P less than 0.01 for the experimental group, P less than 0.05 for the control group). The number of preventive visits was higher in the prepaid groups, but this difference does not explain the reduced hospitalization. The similarity of use between the two prepaid groups suggests that the mix of health risks at the Cooperative was similar to that in the fee-for-service system. The lower rate of use that we observed, along with comparable reductions found in non-controlled studies by others, suggests that the style of medicine at prepaid group practices is markedly less "hospital-intensive" and, consequently, less expensive.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Pracht, E. E.
(2007). State Medicaid Managed Care Enrollment: Understanding the Political Calculus That Drives Medicaid Managed Care Reforms. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
32: 685-731
[Abstract]
Schwenkglenks, M., Preiswerk, G., Lehner, R., Weber, F., Szucs, T. D
(2006). Economic efficiency of gatekeeping compared with fee for service plans: a Swiss example. J. Epidemiol. Community Health
60: 24-30
[Abstract][Full Text]
Bodenheimer, T.
(2005). High and Rising Health Care Costs. Part 3: The Role of Health Care Providers. ANN INTERN MED
142: 996-1002
[Abstract][Full Text]
Pati, S., Shea, S., Rabinowitz, D., Carrasquillo, O.
(2005). Health Expenditures for Privately Insured Adults Enrolled in Managed Care Gatekeeping vs Indemnity Plans. AJPH
95: 286-291
[Abstract][Full Text]
Pauly, M. V.
(2004). Conflict and Compromise Over Tradeoffs in Universal Health Insurance Plans. J Law Med Ethics
32: 465-473
Friedman, B., Devers, K. J., Steiner, C. A., Fox, S.
(2002). The Use of Expensive Health Technologies in the Era of Managed Care: The Remarkable Case of Neonatal Intensive Care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
27: 441-464
[Abstract]
Hutchison, B., Abelson, J., Lavis, J.
(2001). Primary Care In Canada: So Much Innovation, So Little Change. Health Aff (Millwood)
20: 116-131
[Abstract][Full Text]
Canto, J. G., Rogers, W. J., French, W. J., Gore, J. M., Chandra, N. C., Barron, H. V., for the National Registry of Myocardial Infarction,
(2000). Payer Status and the Utilization of Hospital Resources in Acute Myocardial Infarction: A Report From the National Registry of Myocardial Infarction 2. Arch Intern Med
160: 817-823
[Abstract][Full Text]
Conrad, D. A., Koos, S., Harney, A., Haase, M.
(1999). Physician Practice Management Organizations: Their Prospects and Performance. Med Care Res Rev
56: 307-339
[Abstract]
Riley, G. F., Potosky, A. L., Klabunde, C. N., Warren, J. L., Ballard-Barbash, R.
(1999). Stage at Diagnosis and Treatment Patterns Among Older Women With Breast Cancer: An HMO and Fee-for-Service Comparison. JAMA
281: 720-726
[Abstract][Full Text]
Milstein, A.
(1999). An Employer's Perspective on Hospitalists as a Source of Improved Health Care Value. ANN INTERN MED
130: 360-363
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rich, E. C., Kralewski, J., Feldman, R., Dowd, B., Bernhardt, T. S.
(1998). Variations in the Management of Primary Care: Effect on Cost in an HMO Network. Arch Intern Med
158: 2363-2371
[Abstract][Full Text]
Schwartz, C. E, Brotman, S., LaRocca, N., Lee, H.
(1998). Patient perception of quality of care provided by specialists and generalists. Mult Scler
4: 426-432
[Abstract]
Every, N. R., Cannon, C. P., Granger, C., Moliterno, D. J., Aguirre, F. V., Talley, J. D., Booth, J., Sapp, S., Ferguson, J. J., for the GUARANTEE investigators,
(1998). Influence of insurance type on the use of procedures, medications and hospital outcome in patients with unstable angina: results from the GUARANTEE registry. J Am Coll Cardiol
32: 387-392
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hellinger, F. J.
(1998). The Effect of Managed Care on Quality: A Review of Recent Evidence. Arch Intern Med
158: 833-841
[Abstract][Full Text]
Conrad, D. A., Maynard, C., Cheadle, A., Ramsey, S., Marcus-Smith, M., Kirz, H., Madden, C. A., Martin, D., Perrin, E. B., Wickizer, T., Zierler, B., Ross, A., Noren, J., Liang, S.-Y.
(1998). Primary Care Physician Compensation Method in Medical Groups: Does It Influence the Use and Cost of Health Services for Enrollees in Managed Care Organizations?. JAMA
279: 853-858
[Abstract][Full Text]
Retchin, S. M., Penberthy, L., Desch, C., Brown, R., Jerome-D'Emilia, B., Clement, D.
(1997). Perioperative Management of Colon Cancer Under Medicare Risk Programs. Arch Intern Med
157: 1878-1884
[Abstract]
Bograd, H., Ritzwoller, D. P., Calonge, N., Shields, K., Hanrahan, M.
(1997). Extending Health Maintenance Organization Insurance to the Uninsured: A Controlled Measure of Health Care Utilization. JAMA
277: 1067-1072
[Abstract]
Asch, S., Goldzweig, C. L., Lee, P.
(1997). Do We Understand the Effects of 'Managed Care' in Ophthalmology? A Review and Analysis. Arch Ophthalmol
115: 531-536
[Abstract]
Oberlander, J. B.
(1997). Managed Care and Medicare Reform. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
22: 595-631
[Abstract]
Meyer, T. J., Prochazka, A. V., Hannaford, M., Fryer, G. E.
(1996). Randomized Controlled Trial of Residents as Gatekeepers. Arch Intern Med
156: 2483-2487
[Abstract]
Ware, J. E. Jr, Bayliss, M. S., Rogers, W. H., Kosinski, M., Tarlov, A. R.
(1996). Differences in 4-Year Health Outcomes for Elderly and Poor, Chronically III Patients Treated in HMO and Fee-for-Service Systems: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
276: 1039-1047
[Abstract]
Yelin, E. H., Criswell, L. A., Feigenbaum, P. G.
(1996). Health Care Utilization and Outcomes Among Persons With Rheumatoid Arthritis in Fee-for-Service and Prepaid Group Practice Settings. JAMA
276: 1048-1053
[Abstract]
Robinson, J. C.
(1996). Decline in Hospital Utilization and Cost Inflation Under Managed Care in California. JAMA
276: 1060-1064
[Abstract]
Hellinger, F. J.
(1996). The Impact of Financial Incentives on Physician Behavior in Managed Care Plans: A Review of the Evidence. Med Care Res Rev
53: 294-314
[Abstract]
Wallack, S. S., Skwara, K. C., Cai, J.
(1996). Redefining Rate Regulation in a Competitive Environment. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
21: 489-510
[Abstract]
Howard, K. I., Cornille, T. A., Lyons, J. S., Vessey, J. T., Lueger, R. J., Saunders, S. M.
(1996). Patterns of Mental Health Service Utilization. Arch Gen Psychiatry
53: 696-703
[Abstract]
West, D. W., Stuart, M. E., Duggan, A. K., DeAngelis, C. D.
(1996). Evidence for Selective Health Maintenance Organization Enrollment Among Children and Adolescents Covered by Medicaid. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
150: 503-507
[Abstract]
Greenfield, S., Rogers, W., Mangotich, M., Carney, M. F., Tarlov, A. R.
(1995). Outcomes of Patients With Hypertension and Non--insulin-dependentn Diabetes Mellitus Treated by Different Systems and Specialties: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
274: 1436-1444
[Abstract]
Paone, G., Higgins, R. S.D., Spencer, T., Silverman, N. A.
(1995). Enrollment in the Health Alliance Plan HMO Is Not an Independent Risk Factor for Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery. Circulation
92: 69-72
[Abstract][Full Text]
Taylor, A. K., Beauregard, K. M., Vistnes, J. P.
(1995). Who Belongs to HMOs: A Comparison of Fee-for-Service versus HMO Enrollees. Med Care Res Rev
52: 389-408
[Abstract]
Schut, F. T.
(1995). Health Care Reform in the Netherlands: Balancing Corporatism, Etatism, and Market Mechanisms. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
20: 615-652
[Abstract]
Chernew, M.
(1995). HMO Use of Diagnostic Tests: A Review of the Evidence. Med Care Res Rev
52: 196-222
[Abstract]
Feldman, R., Wholey, D., Christianson, J.
(1995). A Descriptive Economic Analysis of HMO Mergers and Failures, 1985-1992. Med Care Res Rev
52: 279-304
[Abstract]
Grumbach, K., Bodenheimer, T.
(1995). Mechanisms for Controlling Costs. JAMA
273: 1223-1230
[Abstract]
Fleming, S. T.
(1995). Primary Care, Avoidable Hospitalization, and Outcomes of Care: A Literature Review and Methodological Approach. Med Care Res Rev
52: 88-108
[Abstract]
Sloan, F. A., Conover, C. J., Shayne, M. W.
(1995). Continuing Care Retirement Communities: Prospects for Reducing Institutional Long-Term Care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
20: 75-98
[Abstract]
Braveman, P., Schaaf, V. M., Egerter, S., Bennett, T., Schecter, W.
(1994). Insurance-Related Differences in the Risk of Ruptured Appendix. NEJM
331: 444-449
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ermann, D., Richmond, J.
(1994). Managed Care Arrangements: Barriers to Cost Savings Potential. Med Care Res Rev
51: 125-148
Safran, D. G., Tarlov, A. R., Rogers, W. H.
(1994). Primary Care Performance in Fee-for-Service and Prepaid Health Care Systems: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
271: 1579-1586
[Abstract]
Miller, R. H., Luft, H. S.
(1994). Managed Care Plan Performance Since 1980: A Literature Analysis. JAMA
271: 1512-1519
[Abstract]
Marquis, M. S., Buchanan, J. L.
(1994). How Will Changes in Health Insurance Tax Policy and Employer Health Plan Contributions Affect Access to Health Care and Health Care Costs?. JAMA
271: 939-944
[Abstract]
Langa, K. M., Sussman, E. J.
(1993). The Effect of Cost-Containment Policies on Rates of Coronary Revascularization in California. NEJM
329: 1784-1789
[Abstract][Full Text]
Weiner, J. P.
(1993). The Demand for Physician Services in a Changing Health Care System: A Synthesis. Med Care Res Rev
50: 411-449
Franks, P., Nutting, P. A., Clancy, C. M.
(1993). Health Care Reform, Primary Care, and the Need for Research. JAMA
270: 1449-1453
[Abstract]
Halpin Schauffler, H., Rodriguez, T.
(1993). Managed Care for Preventive Services: A Review of Policy Options. Med Care Res Rev
50: 153-198
Wright, R. A.
(1993). Community-Oriented Primary Care: The Cornerstone of Health Care Reform. JAMA
269: 2544-2547
[Abstract]
Finkel, M. L.
(1993). Managed Care Is Not the Answer. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18: 105-112
Rapoport, J., Gehlbach, S., Lemeshow, S., Teres, D.
(1992). Resource Utilization Among Intensive Care Patients: Managed Care vs Traditional Insurance. Arch Intern Med
152: 2207-2212
[Abstract]
Lurie, N., Moscovice, I. S., Finch, M., Christianson, J. B., Popkin, M. K.
(1992). Does Capitation Affect the Health of the Chronically Mentally III? Results From a Randomized Trial. JAMA
267: 3300-3304
[Abstract]
Greenfield, S., Nelson, E. C., Zubkoff, M., Manning, W., Rogers, W., Kravitz, R. L., Keller, A., Tarlov, A. R., Ware, J. E. Jr
(1992). Variations in Resource Utilization Among Medical Specialties and Systems of Care: Results From the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA
267: 1624-1630
[Abstract]
Rice, T.
(1992). Containing Health Care Costs in the United States. Med Care Res Rev
49: 19-65
Buchanan, J. L., Leibowitz, A., Lindsey, P. A., Davies, A. s. R.
(1992). HMOs for Medicaid: The Road to Financial Independence Is Often Poorly Paved. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
17: 71-96
[Abstract]
Brown, E. R.
(1992). Health USA: A National Health Program for the United States. JAMA
267: 552-558
[Abstract]
Robinson, J. C.
(1991). HMO Market Penetration and Hospital Cost Inflation in California. JAMA
266: 2719-2723
[Abstract]
Udvarhelyi, I. S., Jennison, K., Phillips, R. S., Epstein, A. M.
(1991). Comparison of the Quality of Ambulatory Care for Fee-for-Service and Prepaid Patients. ANN INTERN MED
115: 394-400
[Abstract]
Heidrich, F. E., Stergachis, A., Gross, K. M.
(1991). Diuretic Drug Use and the Risk for Hip Fracture. ANN INTERN MED
115: 1-6
[Abstract]
Stergachis, A., Shy, K. K., Grothaus, L. C., Wagner, E. H., Hecht, J. A., Anderson, G., Normand, E. H., Raboud, J.
(1990). Tubal Sterilization and the Long-term Risk of Hysterectomy. JAMA
264: 2893-2898
[Abstract]
Carey, T. S., Weis, K.
(1990). Diagnostic Testing and Return Visits for Acute Problems in Prepaid, Case-Managed Medicaid Plans Compared With Fee-for-Service. Arch Intern Med
150: 2369-2372
[Abstract]
Szilagyi, P. G., Roghmann, K. J., Foye, H. R., Parks, C., MacWhinney, J., Miller, R., Nazarian, L., Mclnerny, T., Klein, S.
(1990). The Effect of Independent Practice Association Plans on Use of Pediatric Ambulatory Medical Care in One Group Practice. JAMA
263: 2198-2203
[Abstract]
Aaron, H, Schwartz, W.
(1990). Rationing health care: the choice before us. Science
247: 418-422
[Abstract]
De Alessi, L.
(1989). The Effect of Institutions on the Choices of Consumers and Providers of Health Care. Journal of Theoretical Politics
1: 427-458
[Abstract]
Sofaer, S., Kenney, E.
(1989). Financial Consequences of Joining a Medicare HMO: An Application of the Illness Episode Approach to Estimating Out-of-Pocket Costs. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
14: 565-585
[Abstract]
Tarlov, A. R., Ware, J. E. Jr, Greenfield, S., Nelson, E. C., Perrin, E., Zubkoff, M.
(1989). The Medical Outcomes Study: An Application of Methods for Monitoring the Results of Medical Care. JAMA
262: 925-930
[Abstract]
Stern, R. S., Juhn, P. I., Gertler, P. J., Epstein, A. M.
(1989). A Comparison of Length of Stay and Costs for Health Maintenance Organization and Fee-for-Service Patients. Arch Intern Med
149: 1185-1188
[Abstract]
Bodenheimer, T. S.
(1989). Payment Mechanisms under a National Health Program. Med Care Res Rev
46: 3-43
Newhouse, J. P.
(1988). Has the Erosion of the Medical Marketplace Ended?. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
13: 263-278
[Abstract]
Altman, S. H., Rodwin, M. A.
(1988). Halfway Competitive Markets and Ineffective Regulation: The American Health Care System. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
13: 323-339
[Abstract]
Siu, A. L., Leibowitz, A., Brook, R. H., Goldman, N. S., Lurie, N., Newhouse, J. P.
(1988). Use of the Hospital in a Randomized Trial of Prepaid Care. JAMA
259: 1343-1346
[Abstract]
Schwartz, W. B., Williams, A. P., Newhouse, J. P., Witsberger, C.
(1988). Are We Training Too Many Medical Subspecialists?. JAMA
259: 233-239
[Abstract]
Brook, R. H., Lohr, K. N.
(1987). Monitoring Quality of Care in the Medicare Program: Two Proposed Systems. JAMA
258: 3138-3141
[Abstract]
Schwartz, W. B.
(1987). The Inevitable Failure of Cost-Containment Strategies-Reply. JAMA
257: 2030-2030
[Abstract]
Nycz, G. R., Wenzel, F. J., Freisinger, R. J., Lewis, R. F.
(1987). Medicare Risk Contracting: Lessons From an Unsuccessful Demonstration. JAMA
257: 656-659
[Abstract]
Schwartz, W. B.
(1987). The Inevitable Failure of Current Cost-Containment Strategies: Why They Can Provide Only Temporary Relief. JAMA
257: 220-224
[Abstract]
SLOSS, E. M., KEELER, E. B., BROOK, R. H., OPERSKALSKI, B. H., GOLDBERG, G. A., NEWHOUSE, J. P.
(1987). Effect of a Health Maintenance Organization on Physiologic Health: Results from a Randomized Trial. ANN INTERN MED
106: 130-138
[Abstract]
Valenzuela, T. D., Hook, E. W. III, Copass, M. K., Corey, L.
(1985). Occupational Exposure to Hepatitis B in Paramedics. Arch Intern Med
145: 1976-1977
[Abstract]
SECHREST, L.
(1985). Evaluating Health Care. American Behavioral Scientist
28: 527-542
Previous
