We investigated decisions to withhold or withdraw life support from patients in the medical-surgical intensive care units at the Moffitt-Long Hospital of the University of California and San Francisco General Hospital, from July 1987 through June 1988. Among 1719 patients admitted to the two intensive care units, life support was withheld from 22 (1 percent) and withdrawn from 93 (5 percent). The reason for limiting care was poor prognosis. Of these 115 patients (18 of whom were considered brain-dead), 89 died in the intensive care unit (accounting for 45 percent of all deaths there), and all but 1 of the remaining patients died after transfer from the intensive care unit. Thirteen (11 percent) had earlier expressed the wish that their terminal care be limited, but this affected care in only four cases. Only 5 of the 115 patients made the actual decision to limit care; the others were incompetent at the time. Of the latter, 102 had families who participated in the decision; family members of the other 8 incompetent patients could not be found, and the decisions were made by physicians. Only 10 families initially disagreed with the recommendations to limit care, and they later agreed. The median duration of intensive care among the patients from whom life support was withheld or withdrawn was eight days at Moffitt-Long Hospital and four days at San Francisco General, as compared with medians of three and one days, respectively, for other patients who died in the intensive care units. We conclude that although life-sustaining care is withheld or withdrawn relatively infrequently from patients in the intensive care unit, such decisions precipitate about half of all deaths in the intensive care units of the hospitals we studied. In most of these cases the patients are incompetent, but physicians and families usually agree to limit care.
Source Information
Department of Surgery, University of California, San Francisco.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Hansen, L., Goodell, T. T., DeHaven, J., Smith, M.
(2009). Nurses' Perceptions of End-of-Life Care After Multiple Interventions for Improvement. Am J Crit Care
18: 263-271
[Abstract][Full Text]
Mularski, R. A., Puntillo, K., Varkey, B., Erstad, B. L., Grap, M. J., Gilbert, H. C., Li, D., Medina, J., Pasero, C., Sessler, C. N.
(2009). Pain Management Within the Palliative and End-of-Life Care Experience in the ICU. Chest
135: 1360-1369
[Abstract][Full Text]
Winkler, E. C., Reiter-Theil, S., Lange-Riess, D., Schmahl-Menges, N., Hiddemann, W.
(2009). Patient Involvement in Decisions to Limit Treatment: The Crucial Role of Agreement Between Physician and Patient. JCO
27: 2225-2230
[Abstract][Full Text]
Gerstel, E., Engelberg, R. A., Koepsell, T., Curtis, J. R.
(2008). Duration of Withdrawal of Life Support in the Intensive Care Unit and Association with Family Satisfaction. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
178: 798-804
[Abstract][Full Text]
Curtis, J. R., Treece, P. D., Nielsen, E. L., Downey, L., Shannon, S. E., Braungardt, T., Owens, D., Steinberg, K. P., Engelberg, R. A.
(2008). Integrating Palliative and Critical Care: Evaluation of a Quality-Improvement Intervention. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
178: 269-275
[Abstract][Full Text]
Shanawani, H., Wenrich, M. D., Tonelli, M. R., Curtis, J. R.
(2008). Meeting Physicians' Responsibilities in Providing End-of-Life Care. Chest
133: 775-786
[Abstract][Full Text]
White, D. B., Curtis, J. R., Wolf, L. E., Prendergast, T. J., Taichman, D. B., Kuniyoshi, G., Acerra, F., Lo, B., Luce, J. M.
(2007). Life Support for Patients without a Surrogate Decision Maker: Who Decides?. ANN INTERN MED
147: 34-40
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ferrand, E, Jabre, P, Fernandez-Curiel, S, Morin, F, Vincent-Genod, C, Duvaldestin, P, Lemaire, F, Herve, C, Marty, J
(2006). Participation of French general practitioners in end-of-life decisions for their hospitalised patients. J. Med. Ethics
32: 683-687
[Abstract][Full Text]
Daly, B. J.
(2006). End-of-Life Decision Making, Organ Donation, and Critical Care Nurses. Crit Care Nurse
26: 78-86
[Full Text]
Jakobson, D. J., Eidelman, L. A., Worner, T. M., Oppenheim, A. E., Pizov, R., Sprung, C. L.
(2004). Evaluation of Changes in Forgoing Life-Sustaining Treatment in Israeli ICU Patients. Chest
126: 1969-1973
[Abstract][Full Text]
Manthous, C. A., DeGirolamo, A., Haddad, C., Amoateng-Adjepong, Y.
(2003). Informed Consent for Medical Procedures: Local and National Practices. Chest
124: 1978-1984
[Abstract][Full Text]
Cook, D., Rocker, G., Marshall, J., Sjokvist, P., Dodek, P., Griffith, L., Freitag, A., Varon, J., Bradley, C., Levy, M., Finfer, S., Hamielec, C., McMullin, J., Weaver, B., Walter, S., Guyatt, G., the Level of Care Study Investigators and the Cana,
(2003). Withdrawal of Mechanical Ventilation in Anticipation of Death in the Intensive Care Unit. NEJM
349: 1123-1132
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ferrand, E., Lemaire, F., Regnier, B., Kuteifan, K., Badet, M., Asfar, P., Jaber, S., Chagnon, J.-L., Renault, A., Robert, R., Pochard, F., Herve, C., Brun-Buisson, C., Duvaldestin, P.
(2003). Discrepancies between Perceptions by Physicians and Nursing Staff of Intensive Care Unit End-of-Life Decisions. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
167: 1310-1315
[Abstract][Full Text]
Campbell, M. L., Guzman, J. A.
(2003). Impact of a Proactive Approach to Improve End-of-Life Care in a Medical ICU. Chest
123: 266-271
[Abstract][Full Text]
Cherniack, E P
(2002). Increasing use of DNR orders in the elderly worldwide: whose choice is it?. J. Med. Ethics
28: 303-307
[Abstract][Full Text]
Kirchhoff, K. T., Walker, L., Hutton, A., Spuhler, V., Cole, B. V., Clemmer, T.
(2002). The Vortex: Families' Experiences With Death in the Intensive Care Unit. Am J Crit Care
11: 200-209
[Abstract][Full Text]
LUCE, J. M., LEMAIRE, F.
(2001). Two Transatlantic Viewpoints on an Ethical Quandary. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
163: 818-821
[Full Text]
LUCE, J. M., ALPERS, A.
(2000). Legal Aspects of Withholding and Withdrawing Life Support from Critically Ill Patients in the United States and Providing Palliative Care to Them. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
162: 2029-2032
[Full Text]
McGee, D. C., Weinacker, A. B., Raffin, T. A.
(2000). Withdrawing Life Support From the Critically Ill. Chest
118: 1238-1239
[Full Text]
Hall, R. I., Rocker, G. M.
(2000). End-of-Life Care in the ICU : Treatments Provided When Life Support Was or Was Not Withdrawn. Chest
118: 1424-1430
[Abstract][Full Text]
Street, K., Ashcroft, R., Henderson, J., Campbell, A. V
(2000). The decision making process regarding the withdrawal or withholding of potential life-saving treatments in a children's hospital. J. Med. Ethics
26: 346-352
[Abstract][Full Text]
Groenewoud, J. H., van der Heide, A., Kester, J. G. C., de Graaff, C. L. M., van der Wal, G., van der Maas, P. J.
(2000). A Nationwide Study of Decisions to Forego Life-Prolonging Treatment in Dutch Medical Practice. Arch Intern Med
160: 357-363
[Abstract][Full Text]
Nelson, J. E., Meier, D. E.
(1999). Palliative Care in the Intensive Care Unit: Part II: Nelson JE, Meier DE Palliative Care in the Intensive Care Unit Part II Intensive Care Med 1999,14 189-199. J Intensive Care Med
14: 189-199
Nelson, J. E., Meier, D. E.
(1999). Palliative Care in the Intensive Care Unit: Part I: Nelson JE, Meier DE Palliative care in the intensive care unit part I J Intensive Care Med 1999,14 130-139. J Intensive Care Med
14: 130-139
Mayer, S. A., Kossoff, S. B.
(1999). Withdrawal of life support in the neurological intensive care unit. Neurology
52: 1602-1602
[Abstract][Full Text]
PRENDERGAST, T. J., CLAESSENS, M. T., LUCE, J. M.
(1998). A National Survey of End-of-life Care for Critically Ill Patients. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
158: 1163-1167
[Abstract][Full Text]
Baldyga, A. P.
(1998). Ethical Issues in the Postoperative Intensive Care Unit. SEMIN CARDIOTHORAC VASC ANESTH
2: 90-98
[Abstract]
Luce, J.
(1997). Making decisions about the forgoing of life-sustaining therapy. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
156: 1715-1718
[Abstract][Full Text]
LANTOS, J. D., MOKALLA, M., MEADOW, W.
(1997). Resource Allocation in Neonatal and Medical ICUs . Epidemiology and Rationing at the Extremes of Life. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
156: 185-189
[Abstract][Full Text]
Faber-Langendoen, K.
(1996). A Multi-institutional Study of Care Given to Patients Dying in Hospitals: Ethical and Practice Implications. Arch Intern Med
156: 2130-2136
[Abstract]
Boyd, K., Teres, D., Rapoport, J., Lemeshow, S.
(1996). The Relationship Between Age and the Use of DNR Orders in Critical Care Patients: Evidence for Age Discrimination. Arch Intern Med
156: 1821-1826
[Abstract]
Meier, D. E., Fuss, B. R., O'Rourke, D., Baskin, S. A., Lewis, M., Morrison, R. S.
(1996). Marked Improvement in Recognition and Completion of Health Care Proxies: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Counseling by Hospital Patient Representatives. Arch Intern Med
156: 1227-1232
[Abstract]
Council on Scientific Affairs, American Medical As, , Davis, R. M., Genel, M., Howe, J. P. III, Karlan, M. S., Kennedy, W. R., Numann, P. A., Riggs, J. A., Skelton, W. D., Slanetz, P. J., Spillman, M. A., Williams, M. A., Young, D. C., Allen, J. R., Rinaldi, R. C., Schwartzberg, J. G., Lynn, J., Teno, J.
(1996). Good Care of the Dying Patient. JAMA
275: 474-478
[Abstract]
Layde, P. M., Beam, C. A., Broste, S. K., Connors, A. F. Jr, Desbiens, N., Lynn, J., Phillips, R. S., Reding, D., Teno, J., Vidaillet, H., Wenger, N.
(1995). Surrogates' Predictions of Seriously Ill Patients' Resuscitation Preferences. Arch Fam Med
4: 518-523
[Abstract]
McCue, J. D.
(1995). The Naturalness of Dying. JAMA
273: 1039-1043
[Abstract]
Tilden, V. P., Toile, S. W., Garland, M. J., Nelson, C. A.
(1995). Decisions About Life-Sustaining Treatment: Impact of Physicians' Behaviors on the Family. Arch Intern Med
155: 633-638
[Abstract]
Cook, D. J., Guyatt, G. H., Jaeschke, R., Reeve, J., Spanier, A., King, D., Molloy, D. W., Willan, A., Streiner, D. L., Canadian Critical Care Trials Group, , Cook, D. J., Tweeddale, M., Bradley, C., Eliopoulos, V., Hales, M. L., Boroomand, K., Berstein, V., Mackenzie, C., Wannamaker, S., Stollery, D. E., Anderson, M., Hamilton, , Johnston, R., Heule, M.K., Roberts, D., Bodnar, S., Pronger, L., Light, B., O'Rourke, K., Thomas, J., Diehl, G., Ihme, S., Kirby, A., Perkin, K., Wexler, R., Robinson, L., Rutledge, F., Janus, G., Petti, K., Kojlak, J., Hamielec, C., Santucci, R., Powles, P., Fuller, H., Upton, P., Hewson, J., Kidd, A., Grilli, A., McLellan, A. P., Miller, M., Buczko, G., Cassidy, M., Ferris, E., Reid, S. R., Burke, M., Lazar, N., Medaglia, M., McLeod, C., Houston, P., Hall, A., Hyland, R., Ip, I., Hulton, L., Mahon, B., Moffatt, S., Menard, J., McIntyre, R., Armstrong, J., Izzi, S., Jones, G., Fortier, W., Spanier, A., Fleiszer, D., Stone, C., Boyer, J., Piccirilli, M., LaRiccia, P., Magder, S., Beauchamps, F., Desbiens, N., DiLorenzo, L., Quesnel, J., Bilodeau, J., Pelletier, C., MacNeil, A. R., Hall, R., Hay, C., Aquino-Russell, C., Wong, P., Fraser, C., Poirier, P., Peters, S., Kunz, C., Warren, E., Cook, D. J., Guyatt, G. H., Jaeschke, R., Molloy, D. W., Reeve,, J., King, D. R., Willan, A., Streiner, D. L., Jones, G., Spanier, A., Cook, D. J., Guyatt, G. H., Willan, A., Maddock, D., Buckingham, L., King, D. R., Ling, E., Reeve, B. K., Reeve, S.
(1995). Determinants in Canadian Health Care Workers of the Decision to Withdraw Life Support From the Critically Ill. JAMA
273: 703-708
[Abstract]
Raffin, T. A.
(1995). Withdrawing Life Support: How Is the Decision Made?. JAMA
273: 738-739
[Abstract]
Pijnenborg, L., van der Maas, P. J., Kardaun, J. W. P. F., Glerum, J. J., van Delden, J. J. M., Looman, C. W. N.
(1995). Withdrawal or Withholding of Treatment at the End of Life: Results of a Nationwide Study. Arch Intern Med
155: 286-292
[Abstract]
Levetown, M., Pollack, M. M., Cuerdon, T. T., Ruttimann, U. E., Glover, J. J.
(1994). Limitations and Withdrawals of Medical Intervention in Pediatric Critical Care. JAMA
272: 1271-1275
[Abstract]
Morrison, R. S., Morrison, E. W., Glickman, D. F.
(1994). Physician Reluctance to Discuss Advance Directives: An Empiric Investigation of Potential Barriers. Arch Intern Med
154: 2311-2318
[Abstract]
Markson, L. J., Fanale, J., Steel, K., Kern, D., Annas, G.
(1994). Implementing Advance Directives in the Primary Care Setting. Arch Intern Med
154: 2321-2327
[Abstract]
Berwick, D. M.
(1994). Eleven Worthy Aims for Clinical Leadership of Health System Reform. JAMA
272: 797-802
[Abstract]
Small, H.
(1994). New Do-Not-Resuscitate Policies. Arch Intern Med
154: 1536-1539
[Abstract]
Lee, D. K. P., Swinburne, A. J., Fedullo, A. J., Wahl, G. W.
(1994). Withdrawing Care: Experience in a Medical Intensive Care Unit. JAMA
271: 1358-1361
[Abstract]
Emanuel, E. J., Emanuel, L. L.
(1994). The Economics of Dying -- The Illusion of Cost Savings at the End of Life. NEJM
330: 540-544
[Full Text]
Murphy, D. J., Finucane, T. E.
(1993). New Do-Not-Resuscitate Policies: A First Step in Cost Control. Arch Intern Med
153: 1641-1648
[Abstract]
Lubitz, J. D., Riley, G. F.
(1993). Trends in Medicare Payments in the Last Year of Life. NEJM
328: 1092-1096
[Abstract][Full Text]
Orentlicher, D.
(1992). The Illusion of Patient Choice in End-of-Life Decisions. JAMA
267: 2101-2104
Greco, P. J., Schulman, K. A., Lavizzo-Mourey, R., Hansen-Flaschen, J.
(1991). The Patient Self-Determination Act and the Future of Advance Directives. ANN INTERN MED
115: 639-643
[Abstract]
Matthay, M. A., Matthay, R. A.
(1991). Critical Care Medicine. JAMA
265: 3109-3111
[Abstract]
Miller, R. J.
(1991). Ethics and hospice physicians. AM J HOSP PALLIAT CARE
8: 17-26
Sprung, C. L.
(1990). Road to Euthanasia or Right to Refuse Care?-Reply. JAMA
264: 1809-1810
[Abstract]
(1990). DECISION TO WITHHOLD LIFE SUPPORT PROVES NOT TO BE CONTENTIOUS. JWatch General
1990: 4-4
[Full Text]
Previous
