BACKGROUND AND METHODS. In a nationally representative population 65 years of age or older, we have demonstrated that about one quarter of coronary angiographies and upper gastrointestinal endoscopies and two thirds of carotid endarterectomies were performed for reasons that were less than medically appropriate. In this paper we examine whether specific characteristics of patients (age, sex, and race), physicians (age, board-certification status, and experience with the procedure), or hospitals (teaching status, profit-making status, and size) predict whether a procedure will be performed appropriately. RESULTS. In general, we found that little of the variability in the appropriateness of care (4 percent or less) could be explained on the basis of standard, easily obtainable data about the patient, the physician, or the hospital. For all three procedures, however, performance in a teaching hospital increased the likelihood that the reasons would be medically appropriate (P = 0.09 for angiography, P = 0.30 for endoscopy, and P less than 0.01 for endarterectomy). In addition, angiographies were more often performed for appropriate reasons in older or more affluent patients (P less than 0.01 for both). Being treated by a surgeon who performed a high rather than a low number of procedures decreased the likelihood of an appropriate endarterectomy by one third, from 40 to 28 percent (P less than 0.01). CONCLUSIONS. Appropriateness of care cannot be closely predicted from many easily determined characteristics of patients, physicians, or hospitals. Thus, for the present, if appropriateness is to be improved it will have to be assessed directly at the level of each patient, hospital, and physician.
Source Information
Health Sciences Program, Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif. 90406.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Murphy, T. P., Soares, G., Kim, M.
(2004). Increase in Utilization of Percutaneous Renal Artery Interventions by Medicare Beneficiaries, 1996-2000. Am. J. Roentgenol.
183: 561-568
[Abstract][Full Text]
Sheikh, K., Bullock, C.
(2003). Sex differences in carotid endarterectomy utilization and 30-day postoperative mortality. Neurology
60: 471-476
[Abstract][Full Text]
Chernew, M.
(2001). General Equilibrium and Marketability in the Health Care Industry. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
26: 885-898
Kressin, N. R., Petersen, L. A.
(2001). Racial Differences in the Use of Invasive Cardiovascular Procedures: Review of the Literature and Prescription for Future Research. ANN INTERN MED
135: 352-366
[Abstract][Full Text]
Johnston, S. C., Fung, L. H., Gillum, L. A., Smith, W. S., Brass, L. M., Lichtman, J. H., Brown, A. N., Wang, D. Z.
(2001). Utilization of Intravenous Tissue-Type Plasminogen Activator for Ischemic Stroke at Academic Medical Centers : The Influence of Ethnicity Editorial Comment : It Is Time to Implement Stroke Practice Improvement Programs and Prevent the Racial Disparity in Stroke Care. Stroke
32: 1061-1068
[Abstract][Full Text]
BRODER, M. S., KANOUSE, D. E., MITTMAN, B. S., BERNSTEIN, S. J.
(2000). The Appropriateness of Recommendations for Hysterectomy. Obstet Gynecol
95: 199-205
[Abstract][Full Text]
Williams, G. R., Jiang, J. G., Matchar, D. B., Samsa, G. P.
(1999). Incidence and Occurrence of Total (First-Ever and Recurrent) Stroke. Stroke
30: 2523-2528
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ringel, S. P.
(1999). Practicing neurology: A delicate balance. Neurology
52: 1526-1526
[Full Text]
Karp, H. R., Flanders, W. D., Shipp, C. C., Taylor, B., Martin, D.
(1998). Carotid Endarterectomy Among Medicare Beneficiaries : A Statewide Evaluation of Appropriateness and Outcome. Stroke
29: 46-52
[Abstract][Full Text]
Horner, R. D., Hoenig, H., Sloane, R., Rubenstein, L. V., Kahn, K. L.
(1997). Racial Differences in the Utilization of Inpatient Rehabilitation Services Among Elderly Stroke Patients. Stroke
28: 19-25
[Abstract][Full Text]
Markus, T., Booth, P. W.
(1995). Managing cleft lip and palate. BMJ
311: 765-765
[Full Text]
Arndt, M., Bradbury, R. C., Golec, J.
(1995). Indications for Hysterectomy: Variation within and Across Hospitals. Med Care Res Rev
52: 342-363
[Abstract]
Gillum, R. F.
(1995). Epidemiology of Carotid Endarterectomy and Cerebral Arteriography in the United States. Stroke
26: 1724-1728
[Abstract][Full Text]
Axon, A T R, Bell, G D, Jones, R H, Quine, M A, McCloy, R F
(1995). Guidelines on appropriate indications for upper gastrointestinal endoscopy. BMJ
310: 853-856
[Full Text]
Longo, D. R., Daugird, A. J.
(1994). Measuring the Quality of Care: Reforming the Health Care System. American Journal of Medical Quality
9: 104-115
[Abstract]
Phelps, C. E.
(1993). The Methodologic Foundations of Studies of the Appropriateness of Medical Care. NEJM
329: 1241-1245
[Full Text]
Zelkovic, M. A., Nicholas, G. G., Reed, J. F.
(1992). Indications for Carotid Endarterectomy: Surgeons vs Neurologists. VASC ENDOVASCULAR SURG
26: 642-648
[Abstract]
Fahey, D. F.
(1992). Projected Responses to Changes in Physician RBRVS Reimbursement: Induced-Demand Theory versus Contingency Theory. Med Care Res Rev
49: 67-91
Previous
