BACKGROUND. To assess possible differences in physicians' practices with respect to diagnostic imaging, we compared the frequency and costs of imaging examinations as performed by primary physicians who used imaging equipment in their offices (self-referring) and as ordered by physicians who always referred patients to radiologists (radiologist-referring). METHODS. Using a large, private insurance-claims data base, we analyzed 65,517 episodes of outpatient care by 6419 physicians for acute upper respiratory symptoms, pregnancy, low back pain, or (in men) difficulty urinating. The respective imaging procedures studied were chest radiography, obstetrical ultrasonography, radiography of the lumbar spine, and excretory urography, cystography, or ultrasonography. RESULTS. For all four clinical presentations, the self-referring physicians obtained imaging examinations 4.0 to 4.5 times more often than the radiologist-referring physicians (P less than 0.0001 for all four). For chest radiography, obstetrical ultrasonography, and lumbar spine radiography, the self-referring physicians charged significantly more than the radiologists for imaging examinations of similar complexity (P less than 0.0001 for all three). The combination of more frequent imaging and higher charges resulted in mean imaging charges per episode of care that were 4.4 to 7.5 times higher for the self-referring physicians (P less than 0.0001). These results were confirmed in a separate analysis that controlled for the specialty of the physician. CONCLUSIONS. Physicians who do not refer their patients to radiologists for medical imaging use imaging examinations more frequently than do physicians who refer their patients to radiologists, and the charges are usually higher when the imaging is done by the self-referring physician. From our results it is not possible to determine which group of physicians uses imaging more appropriately.
Source Information
Department of Radiology, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Swensen, S. J., Dilling, J. A., Milliner, D. S., Zimmerman, R. S., Maples, W. J., Lindsay, M. E., Bartley, G. B.
(2009). Quality: The Mayo Clinic Approach. American Journal of Medical Quality
24: 428-440
[Abstract]
McCollough, C. H., Guimaraes, L., Fletcher, J. G.
(2009). In Defense of Body CT. Am. J. Roentgenol.
193: 28-39
[Abstract][Full Text]
Krestin, G. P.
(2009). Maintaining Identity in a Changing Environment: The Professional and Organizational Future of Radiology. Radiology
250: 612-617
[Full Text]
Hutchinson, M., Greenberg, J. O., Gazelle, G. S., Halpern, E. F.
(2008). On Radiology Referral versus Specialist Referral. Radiology
247: 593-594
[Full Text]
Gazelle, G. S., Halpern, E. F., Ryan, H. S., Tramontano, A. C.
(2007). Utilization of Diagnostic Medical Imaging: Comparison of Radiologist Referral versus Same-Specialty Referral. Radiology
245: 517-522
[Abstract][Full Text]
Nallamothu, B. K., Rogers, M. A. M., Chernew, M. E., Krumholz, H. M., Eagle, K. A., Birkmeyer, J. D.
(2007). Opening of Specialty Cardiac Hospitals and Use of Coronary Revascularization in Medicare Beneficiaries. JAMA
297: 962-968
[Abstract][Full Text]
Berlin, L.
(2005). Errors of Omission. Am. J. Roentgenol.
185: 1416-1421
[Full Text]
DeMaria, A. N.
(2005). The Growth of Diagnostic Imaging Services. J Am Coll Cardiol
45: 2093-2094
[Full Text]
Kostylova, A, Swaine, B, Feldman, D
(2005). Concordance between childhood injury diagnoses from two sources: an injury surveillance system and a physician billing claims database. Inj. Prev.
11: 186-190
[Abstract][Full Text]
Litt, A. W., Ryan, D. R., Batista, D., Perry, K. N., Lewis, R. S., Sunshine, J. H.
(2005). Relative Procedure Intensity with Self-Referral and Radiologist Referral: Extremity Radiography. Radiology
235: 142-147
[Abstract][Full Text]
Berlin, L., Berlin, J. W.
(2005). Leasing Imaging Facilities to Referring Physicians: Fee Shifting or Fee Splitting?. Radiology
234: 44-48
[Full Text]
Choudhry, S., Choudhry, N. K., Brown, A. D.
(2004). Unregulated private markets for health care in Canada? Rules of professional misconduct, physician kickbacks and physician self-referral. CMAJ
170: 1115-1118
[Full Text]
Maitino, A. J., Levin, D. C., Parker, L., Rao, V. M., Sunshine, J. H.
(2003). Practice Patterns of Radiologists and Nonradiologists in Utilization of Noninvasive Diagnostic Imaging among the Medicare Population 1993-1999. Radiology
228: 795-801
[Abstract][Full Text]
Maitino, A. J., Levin, D. C., Parker, L., Rao, V. M., Sunshine, J. H.
(2003). Nationwide Trends in Rates of Utilization of Noninvasive Diagnostic Imaging among the Medicare Population between 1993 and 1999. Radiology
227: 113-117
[Abstract][Full Text]
Kouri, B. E., Parsons, R. G., Alpert, H. R.
(2002). Physician Self-Referral for Diagnostic Imaging: Review of the Empiric Literature. Am. J. Roentgenol.
179: 843-850
[Full Text]
Filly, R. A., Crane, J. P.
(2002). Routine Obstetric Sonography. J Ultrasound Med
21: 713-718
[Full Text]
Wilson, I. B., Dukes, K., Greenfield, S., Kaplan, S., Hillman, B.
(2001). Patients' Role in the Use of Radiology Testing for Common Office Practice Complaints. Arch Intern Med
161: 256-263
[Abstract][Full Text]
Weingarten, S.
(2000). Translating Practice Guidelines Into Patient Care : Guidelines at the Bedside. Chest
118
: 4S-7S
[Abstract][Full Text]
Moskowitz, H., Sunshine, J., Grossman, D., Adams, L., Gelinas, L.
(2000). The Effect of Imaging Guidelines on the Number and Quality of Outpatient Radiographic Examinations. Am. J. Roentgenol.
175: 9-15
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rosen, A. K., Mayer-Oakes, A.
(1998). Developing a Tool for Analyzing Medical Care Utilization of Adult Asthma Patients in Indemnity and Managed Care Plans: Can an Episodes of Care Framework Be Used?. American Journal of Medical Quality
13: 203-212
[Abstract]
Rosen, A. K., Houchens, R. L., Gibson, T. B., Mayer-Oakes, A.
(1998). Developing Episodes of Care for Adult Asthma Patients: A Cautionary Tale*{dagger}. American Journal of Medical Quality
13: 25-35
[Abstract]
Glassman, P. A., Kravitz, R. L., Petersen, L. P., Rolph, J. E.
(1997). Differences in Clinical Decision Making Between Internists and Cardiologists. Arch Intern Med
157: 506-512
[Abstract]
Greenberg, J. O.
(1997). Reducing Rates of Diagnostic Imaging. JAMA
277: 459-459
[Abstract]
Bree, R. L., Kazerooni, E. A., Katz, S. J.
(1997). Reducing Rates of Diagnostic Imaging-Reply. JAMA
277: 459-460
[Abstract]
Bree, R. L., Kazerooni, E. A., Katz, S. J.
(1996). Effect of Mandatory Radiology Consultation on Inpatient Imaging Use: A Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA
276: 1595-1598
[Abstract]
Levinsky, N. G.
(1996). Social, Institutional, and Economic Barriers to the Exercise of Patients' Rights. NEJM
334: 532-534
[Full Text]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(1995). Extreme Risk -- The New Corporate Proposition for Physicians. NEJM
333: 1706-1708
[Full Text]
Hillman, B. J., Olson, G. T., Colbert, R. W., Bernhardt, L. B.
(1995). Responses to a Payment Policy Denying Professional Charges for Diagnostic Imaging by Nonradiologist Physicians. JAMA
274: 885-887
[Abstract]
Langland-Orban, B., Greene, B. R., Vogel, W. B.
(1995). Graduate Education in Health Services Administration: Integrating Business with Clinical Perspectives. Eval Health Prof
18: 217-228
[Abstract]
Brand, D. A., Quam, L., Leatherman, S.
(1995). Medical Practice Profiling: Concepts and Caveats. Med Care Res Rev
52: 223-251
[Abstract]
Miller, M. E., Holahan, J., Welch, W. P.
(1995). Geographic Variations in Physician Service Utilization. Med Care Res Rev
52: 252-278
[Abstract]
Schiff, G. D., Bindman, A. B., Brennan, T. A., Physicians for a National Health Program Quality o, , Schiff, , Bindman, , Bodenheimer, T., Brennan, , Clancy, C., Fein, O., Hellander, I., Himmelstein, D. U., Murray, L. R., Rucker, T. D., Sable, R., Scavorn, J., Shansky, R., Shaffer, E., Slobodkin, D., Tarzynski, S., Woolhandler, S., Young, Q. D.
(1994). A Better-Quality Alternative: Single-Payer National Health System Reform. JAMA
272: 803-808
[Abstract]
Green, A. J., Sutton, S. K., Sconyers, J. M., Reiter, B., Adams, R. L., Emanuel, E. J., Brett, A. S.
(1994). Managed Competition and the Patient-Physician Relationship. NEJM
330: 639-641
[Full Text]
Dietrich, A. J.
(1993). Procedures in Family Practice: What's Best for Your Patients and for You. Arch Fam Med
2: 1028-1030
[Abstract]
Every, N. R., Larson, E. B., Litwin, P. E., Maynard, C., Fihn, S. D., Eisenberg, M. S., Hallstrom, A. P., Martin, J. S., Weaver, W. D., The Myocardial Infarction Triage and Intervention,
(1993). The Association between On-Site Cardiac Catheterization Facilities and the Use of Coronary Angiography after Acute Myocardial Infarction. NEJM
329: 546-551
[Abstract][Full Text]
Thompson, D. F.
(1993). Understanding Financial Conflicts of Interest. NEJM
329: 573-576
[Full Text]
Ruff, C., McLelland, R.
(1993). The Mammography Quality Standards Act of 1992. JAMA
269: 3110-3110
[Abstract]
Brody, B. A.
(1993). The Physician as Professional and the Physician as Honest Businessman. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
119: 495-497
[Abstract]
Kassirer, J. P.
(1993). Medicine at Center Stage. NEJM
328: 1268-1269
[Full Text]
Finkelstein, S. N., Neels, K., Kattlove, H., O'Grady, K. F., Lewin, A. A., Schwade, J. G., Mitchell, J. M., Sunshine, J. H., Doane, W.W., Cohen, S., Parmet, A.J., Smithline, N., Milstein, A., Johnson, G., Swedlow, A., Iserson, K. V., Besses, G. S., Neumann, K. H., Yanes, B., Clark, O. W., Orentlicher, D., Relman, A. S.
(1993). Self-Referral by Physicians. NEJM
328: 1274-1279
[Full Text]
Stone, D. A.
(1993). The Struggle for the Soul of Health Insurance. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18: 287-317
[Abstract]
Hillman, B. J., Olson, G. T., Griffith, P. E., Sunshine, J. H., Joseph, C. A., Kennedy, S. D., Nelson, W. R., Bernhardt, L. B.
(1992). Physicians' Utilization and Charges for Outpatient Diagnostic Imaging in a Medicare Population. JAMA
268: 2050-2054
[Abstract]
Menken, M.
(1992). Cost-Containment and the Practice of Neurology: The Conflict of Canons. Arch Neurol
49: 877-880
[Abstract]
Mitchell, J. M., Scott, E.
(1992). New Evidence of the Prevalence and Scope of Physician Joint Ventures. JAMA
268: 80-84
[Abstract]
Crane, T. S.
(1992). The Problem of Physician Self-referral Under the Medicare and Medicaid Antikickback Statute: The Hanlester Network Case and the Safe Harbor Regulation. JAMA
268: 85-91
[Abstract]
Herschberg, S.
(1992). Potential Conflicts of Interest in the Delivery of Medical Services: An Analysis of the Situation and a Proposal. American Journal of Medical Quality
7: 54-58
[Abstract]
Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs, American, , Clarke, O. W., Glasson, J., August, A. M., Barrasso, J. A., Epps, C. H. Jr, McQuillan, R., Plows, C. W., Puzak, M. A., Wilkins, G. T. Jr, Orentlicher, D., Halkola, K. A., Johnson, K. B., Orentlicher, D., Conley, R. B.
(1992). Conflicts of Interest: Physician Ownership of Medical Facilities. JAMA
267: 2366-2369
[Abstract]
Fahey, D. F.
(1992). Projected Responses to Changes in Physician RBRVS Reimbursement: Induced-Demand Theory versus Contingency Theory. Med Care Res Rev
49: 67-91
Eisenberg, J. M.
(1991). Economics. JAMA
265: 3113-3115
[Abstract]
Gleicher, N.
(1991). Expansion of Health Care to the Uninsured and Underinsured Has to Be Cost-Neutral. JAMA
265: 2388-2390
[Abstract]
(1990). PHYSICIANS WITH IN-OFFICE RADIOLOGY EQUIPMENT ORDER MORE X-RAYS. JWatch General
1990: 4-4
[Full Text]
Levin, D. C., Parker, L., Intenzo, C. M., Sunshine, J. H.
(2002). Recent Rapid Increase in Utilization of Radionuclide Myocardial Perfusion Imaging and Related Procedures: 1996-1998 Practice Patterns. Radiology
222: 144-148
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hillman, B. J., Neiman, H. L.
(2002). Translating Molecular Imaging Research into Radiologic Practice: Summary of the Proceedings of the American College of Radiology Colloquium, April 22-24, 2001. Radiology
222: 19-24
[Abstract][Full Text]
Previous
