BACKGROUND AND METHODS. In 1983 the proportion of health care expenditures consumed by administration in the United States was 60 percent higher than in Canada and 97 percent higher than in Britain. To assess the effects of recent health policy initiatives on the administrative efficiency of health care, we examined four components of administrative costs in the United States and Canada for 1987: insurance overhead, hospital administration, nursing home administration, and physicians' billing and overhead expenses. Most data were provided by the two nations' federal health and statistics agencies, supplemented by state and provincial data and published sources. Because data on physicians' billing costs were limited, we estimated a range for these costs by two methods that rely on different sources of data. All figures are reported in 1987 U.S. dollars. RESULTS. In 1987 health care administration cost between $96.8 billion and $120.4 billion in the United States, amounting to 19.3 to 24.1 percent of total spending on health care, or $400 to $497 per capita. In Canada, between 8.4 and 11.1 percent of health care spending ($117 to $156 per capita) was devoted to administration. Administrative costs in the United States increased 37 percent in real dollars between 1983 and 1987, whereas in Canada they declined. The proportion of health care spending consumed by administration is now at least 117 percent higher in the United States than in Canada and accounts for about half the total difference in health care spending between the two nations. If health care administration in the United States had been as efficient as in Canada, $69.0 billion to $83.2 billion would have been saved in 1987. CONCLUSIONS. The administrative structure of the U.S. health care system is increasingly inefficient as compared with that of Canada's national health program. Recent health policies with the avowed goal of improving the efficiency of care have imposed substantial new bureaucratic costs and burdens.
Source Information
Department of Medicine, Cambridge Hospital, Mass.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Tuohy, C. H.
(2009). Single Payers, Multiple Systems: The Scope and Limits of Subnational Variation under a Federal Health Policy Framework. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
34: 453-496
[Abstract]
Himmelstein, D. U., Woolhandler, S.
(2008). National Health Insurance or Incremental Reform: Aim High, or at Our Feet?. AJPH
98: S65-S68
[Abstract][Full Text]
McCormick, D., Himmelstein, D. U., Woolhandler, S., Bor, D. H.
(2004). Single-Payer National Health Insurance: Physicians' Views. Arch Intern Med
164: 300-304
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rastegar, D. A.
(2004). Health Care Becomes an Industry. Ann Fam Med
2: 79-83
[Abstract][Full Text]
Woolhandler, S., Campbell, T., Himmelstein, D. U.
(2003). Costs of Health Care Administration in the United States and Canada. NEJM
349: 768-775
[Abstract][Full Text]
Aaron, H. J.
(2003). The Costs of Health Care Administration in the United States and Canada -- Questionable Answers to a Questionable Question. NEJM
349: 801-803
[Full Text]
The Physicians' Working Group for Single-Payer Nat,
(2003). Proposal of the Physicians' Working Group for Single-Payer National Health Insurance. JAMA
290: 798-805
[Abstract][Full Text]
McCanne, D.
(2003). Why Incremental Reforms Will Not Solve the Health Care Crisis. J Am Board Fam Med
16: 257-261
[Full Text]
Himmelstein, D. U., Woolhandler, S.
(2003). National Health Insurance or Incremental Reform: Aim High, or at Our Feet?. AJPH
93: 102-105
[Abstract][Full Text]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(2002). Paying For National Health Insurance--And Not Getting It. Health Aff (Millwood)
21: 88-98
[Abstract][Full Text]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(2002). National Health Insurance: Liberal Benefits, Conservative Spending. Arch Intern Med
162: 973-975
[Full Text]
Hurley, J.
(2001). Ethics, economics, and public financing of health care. J. Med. Ethics
27: 234-239
[Abstract][Full Text]
Zelenock, G. B., Zambricki, C. S.
(2001). The Health Care Crisis: Impact on Surgery in the Community Hospital Setting. Arch Surg
136: 585-591
[Abstract][Full Text]
Collins, J. A., Ishida, Y., Long, J., Pecora, J. L., White, B. L., Reich, J. D., Starfield, B.
(2000). Deficiencies in US Medical Care. JAMA
284: 2184-2185
[Full Text]
Pollner, P., Wooten, N., Volpintesta, E. J., Yarmolinsky, A., Larkin, G. L., Marco, C. A., Fields, W., Fletcher, R.
(1999). Managed Care, Charity Care, and the Common Good. JAMA
282: 1619-1621
[Full Text]
Roberts, R. R., Frutos, P. W., Ciavarella, G. G., Gussow, L. M., Mensah, E. K., Kampe, L. M., Straus, H. E., Joseph, G., Rydman, R. J.
(1999). Distribution of Variable vs Fixed Costs of Hospital Care. JAMA
281: 644-649
[Abstract][Full Text]
Herzlinger, R. E.
(1999). Finding "Truth" about Managed Care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
24: 1077-1093
Schrecker, T.
(1998). Private Health Care for Canada: North of the Border, an Idea Whose Time Shouldn't Come?. J Law Med Ethics
26: 138-148
Glick, H. A., Polsky, D., Willke, R. J., Alves, W. M., Kassell, N., Schulman, K.
(1998). Comparison of the Use of Medical Resources and Outcomes in the Treatment of Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Between Canada and the United States. Stroke
29: 351-358
[Abstract][Full Text]
Sumner, B., Dowd, B., Pheley, A. M., Lurie, N.
(1997). Denial of Health Insurance due to Preexisting Conditions: How Well does One High-Risk Pool Work?. Med Care Res Rev
54: 357-371
[Abstract]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(1997). Costs of Care and Administration at For-Profit and Other Hospitals in the United States. NEJM
336: 769-774
[Abstract][Full Text]
Jackson, J. L.
(1997). The German Health System: Lessons for Reform in the United States. Arch Intern Med
157: 155-160
[Abstract]
Evans, R. G.
(1997). Going for the Gold: The Redistributive Agenda behind Market-Based Health Care Reform. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
22: 427-465
[Abstract]
GOTTLIEB, S., EINHORN, T. A.
(1997). Current Concepts Review - Managed Care: Form, Function, and Evolution. JBJS
79: 125-36
[Full Text]
Evans, J. G.
(1996). Health Care for Older People: A Look Across a Frontier. JAMA
275: 1449-1450
[Abstract]
Leibowitz, A., Hanchak, N. A., Schlackman, N., Lebow, R., Spanknebel, G. L., Peck, C., Eleff, M., Devereaux, M. W., Thompson, M. A., Royce, P. C., Zwerner, A. R., Baker, S. S., Druker, D., Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(1996). Corporate Managed Care. NEJM
334: 1060-1063
[Full Text]
Nayeri, K.
(1995). Economic Boundaries of Health Care: Factors Influencing Reform Proposals. Review of Radical Political Economics
27: 56-82
[Abstract]
Barer, M. L.
(1995). So Near, and Yet So Far: A Canadian Perspective on U.S. Health Care Reform. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
20: 463-476
Rasell, M. E.
(1995). Cost Sharing in Health Insurance -- A Reexamination. NEJM
332: 1164-1168
[Full Text]
Emanuel, E. J., Dubler, N. N.
(1995). Preserving the Physician-Patient Relationship in the Era of Managed Care. JAMA
273: 323-329
[Abstract]
Grumbach, K., Bodenheimer, T.
(1994). Painful vs Painless Cost Control. JAMA
272: 1458-1464
[Abstract]
Berwick, D. M.
(1994). Eleven Worthy Aims for Clinical Leadership of Health System Reform. JAMA
272: 797-802
[Abstract]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U.
(1994). Correction: The Deteriorating Administrative Efficiency of the U.S. Health Care System. NEJM
331: 336-336
[Full Text]
Bergman, A. B.
(1994). Meeting Mania. NEJM
330: 1622-1623
[Full Text]
McDermott, J.
(1994). Evaluating Health System Reform: The Case for a Single-Payer Approach. JAMA
271: 782-784
[Abstract]
Emanuel, E. J., Emanuel, L. L.
(1994). The Economics of Dying -- The Illusion of Cost Savings at the End of Life. NEJM
330: 540-544
[Full Text]
Saultz, J.
(1994). Rural Health: A Broader Perspective. Arch Fam Med
3: 119-121
[Abstract]
Hamilton, V., Benk, V., Fortin, P., Ayanian, J. Z., Kohler, B. A., Epstein, A. M.
(1993). Health Insurance Coverage and Clinical Outcomes in Women with Breast Cancer. NEJM
329: 2039-2040
[Full Text]
Schuster, J. M.
(1993). Managed Care and Mental Health Services: Lessons for Health Care Providers. American Journal of Medical Quality
8: 200-203
[Abstract]
Epstein, A. M.
(1993). Changes in the Delivery of Care under Comprehensive Health Care Reform. NEJM
329: 1672-1676
[Full Text]
Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U., Lewontin, J. P.
(1993). Administrative Costs in U.S. Hospitals. NEJM
329: 400-403
[Abstract][Full Text]
ROSENAU, P. V.
(1993). Some Reasoned Utopian Proposals for National Health System Reform in the United States. American Behavioral Scientist
36: 871-886
[Abstract]
Angell, M.
(1993). How Much Will Health Care Reform Cost?. NEJM
328: 1778-1779
[Full Text]
Wellstone, P. D., Shaffer, E. R.
(1993). The American Health Security Act -- A Single-Payer Proposal. NEJM
328: 1489-1493
[Full Text]
Crandall, S. J. S., Volk, R. J., Loemker, V.
(1993). Medical Students' Attitudes Toward Providing Care for the Underserved: Are We Training Socially Responsible Physicians?. JAMA
269: 2519-2523
[Abstract]
Grumbach, K., Fry, J.
(1993). Managing Primary Care in the United States and in the United Kingdom. NEJM
328: 940-945
[Full Text]
Redelmeier, D. A., Fuchs, V. R.
(1993). Hospital Expenditures in the United States and Canada. NEJM
328: 772-778
[Abstract][Full Text]
Mechanic, D.
(1993). America's Health Care System and its Future: The View of a Despairing Optimist. Med Care Res Rev
50: 7-48
Siu, A. L.
(1993). Conflicting Aims: Voluntary Health Insurance and Contemporary Medical Practice. Arch Intern Med
153: 457-463
[Abstract]
Fuchs, V. R.
(1993). No Pain, No Gain: Perspectives on Cost Containment. JAMA
269: 631-633
[Abstract]
Finkel, M. L.
(1993). Managed Care Is Not the Answer. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18: 105-112
Peterson, M. A.
(1993). Political Influence in the 1990s: From Iron Triangles to Policy Networks. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18: 395-438
[Abstract]
Rochefort, D. A.
(1993). The Pragmatic Appeal of Employment-based Health Care Reform. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18: 683-693
Barer, M. L., Hertzman, C., Miller, R., Pascali, M. V.
(1992). On Being Old and Sick: The Burden of Health Care for the Elderly in Canada and the United States. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
17: 763-782
[Abstract]
(1992). Living With Hippocrates in a Changing Medical World, With Particular Reference to the Patient-Physician Relationship: Just as you ought not attempt to cure eyes without head or head without body, so you should not treat body without soul. Socrates. Arch Intern Med
152: 2184-2188
[Abstract]
Mount, B. M.
(1992). Keeping the mission. AM J HOSP PALLIAT CARE
9: 32-37
Waitzkin, H., Hubbell, F. A.
(1992). Truth's Search for Power in Health Policy: Critical Applications to Community-Oriented Primary Care and Small Area Analysis. Med Care Res Rev
49: 161-189
Barrilleaux, C. J., Miller, M. E.
(1992). Decisions without Consequences: Cost Control and Access in State Medicaid Programs. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
17: 97-118
[Abstract]
Brown, E. R.
(1992). Health USA: A National Health Program for the United States. JAMA
267: 552-558
[Abstract]
Casalino, L. P.
(1992). Balancing Incentives: How Should Physicians Be Reimbursed?. JAMA
267: 403-405
[Abstract]
Shortliffe, E. H., Tang, P. C., Detmer, D. E.
(1991). Patient Records and Computers. ANN INTERN MED
115: 979-981
[Abstract]
Harrington, C., Cassel, C., Estes, C. L., Woolhandler, S., Himmelstein, D. U., the Working Group on Long-term Care Program Design,
(1991). A National Long-term Care Program for the United States: A Caring Vision. JAMA
266: 3023-3029
[Abstract]
Smith, C. B., Wolcott, M.
(1991). Veterans Health Care: Lessons for a National Health Care System. ANN INTERN MED
115: 907-909
[Abstract]
Albright, J. A.
(1991). The Costs of Doctoring, the Distribution of Physicians, and Caring for the Underinsured. JAMA
266: 1510-1510
[Abstract]
(1991). ADMINISTRATIVE INEFFICIENCY IN THE U.S. HEALTH CARE SYSTEM. JWatch General
1991: 2-2
[Full Text]
A correction has been published: N Engl J Med 1994;331(5):336.
Previous
