BACKGROUND. Osteoporosis among older women is a major public health problem. We studied the effects of three approaches to the prevention of osteoporosis in women with low bone density. METHODS. One hundred twenty postmenopausal women (mean [+/- SD] age, 56 +/- 4) who were selected because they had low forearm bone density were enrolled in a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized study comparing the effects of an exercise regimen (exercise group, n = 41), exercise plus dietary calcium supplementation (exercise-calcium group, n = 39), and exercise plus continuous replacement of estrogen and progesterone (exercise-estrogen group, n = 40). Periodically during the two-year study period, we measured the women's bone density at three forearm sites, measured indexes of calcium metabolism, and recorded symptom scores. A comparison group of 42 women (mean age, 55.5 +/- 3.1) with normal bone density was also followed for two years. RESULTS. Significant bone loss in the distal forearm occurred in the group with normal bone density (control group) and the exercise group (change, -2.7 percent and -2.6 percent of the base-line value per year, respectively). Bone loss at the distal forearm site was significantly lower in the exercise-calcium group (-0.5 percent of the base-line value per year), and bone density increased at this site in the exercise-estrogen group (+2.7 percent of the base-line value per year). Bone loss at the median forearm site was significantly lower in the exercise-calcium group (-1.3 percent of the base-line value per year) than in the exercise group (-2.4 percent), and bone density at this site increased significantly in the exercise-estrogen group (+0.8 percent of the base-line value per year). Breast tenderness occurred in 47 percent of the women in the exercise-estrogen group but in only 20 percent in the other two treatment groups. Vaginal bleeding occurred at some time in 52 percent of the women who had not had a hysterectomy in the exercise-estrogen group, as compared with 11 percent and 12.5 percent, respectively, in the exercise and exercise-calcium groups. CONCLUSIONS. In postmenopausal women with low bone density, bone loss can be slowed or prevented by exercise plus calcium supplementation or estrogen-progesterone replacement. Although the exercise-estrogen regimen was more effective than exercise and calcium supplementation in increasing bone mass, it also caused more side effects.
Source Information
University Department of Medicine, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, Nedlands, Western Australia.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Woo, J., Hong, A., Lau, E., Lynn, H.
(2007). A randomised controlled trial of Tai Chi and resistance exercise on bone health, muscle strength and balance in community-living elderly people. Age Ageing
36: 262-268
[Abstract][Full Text]
Wildschut, H. I.J., Peters, T.J., Weiner, C. P.
(2006). Screening in women's health, with emphasis on fetal Down's syndrome, breast cancer and osteoporosis. Hum Reprod Update
12: 499-512
[Abstract][Full Text]
Prince, R. L., Devine, A., Dhaliwal, S. S., Dick, I. M.
(2006). Effects of Calcium Supplementation on Clinical Fracture and Bone Structure: Results of a 5-Year, Double-blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial in Elderly Women.. Arch Intern Med
166: 869-875
[Abstract][Full Text]
Maimoun, L, Simar, D, Malatesta, D, Caillaud, C, Peruchon, E, Couret, I, Rossi, M, Mariano-Goulart, D
(2005). Response of bone metabolism related hormones to a single session of strenuous exercise in active elderly subjects. Br. J. Sports. Med.
39: 497-502
[Abstract][Full Text]
Rabon-Stith, K. M, Hagberg, J. M, Phares, D. A, Kostek, M. C, Delmonico, M. J, Roth, S. M, Ferrell, R. E, Conway, J. M, Ryan, A. S, Hurley, B. F
(2005). Vitamin D receptor FokI genotype influences bone mineral density response to strength training, but not aerobic training. Exp Physiol
90: 653-661
[Abstract][Full Text]
Dick, I. M., Devine, A., Beilby, J., Prince, R. L.
(2005). Effects of endogenous estrogen on renal calcium and phosphate handling in elderly women. Am. J. Physiol. Endocrinol. Metab.
288: E430-E435
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hoenderop, J. G. J., Nilius, B., Bindels, R. J. M.
(2005). Calcium Absorption Across Epithelia. Physiol. Rev.
85: 373-422
[Abstract][Full Text]
Auer, J., Lamm, G., Eber, B., Bursztyn, M., Perez-Castrillon, J. L., Arranz-Pena, M. L., Luis, D. D., Ellenberg, S. S., Orloff, D. G., Temple, R. J., McLean, R. R., Kiel, D. P., van Meurs, J. B.J., Pols, H. A.P., Uitterlinden, A. G., Raisz, L. G.
(2004). Homocysteine as a Predictive Factor for Hip Fracture in Older Persons. NEJM
351: 1027-1030
[Full Text]
Ho, S. C., Chen, Y.-M., Woo, J. L. F., Lam, S. S. H.
(2004). High Habitual Calcium Intake Attenuates Bone Loss in Early Postmenopausal Chinese Women: An 18-Month Follow-Up Study. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab.
89: 2166-2170
[Abstract][Full Text]
Eichner, S. F, Lloyd, K. B, Timpe, E. M
(2003). Comparing Therapies for Postmenopausal Osteoporosis Prevention and Treatment. The Annals of Pharmacotherapy
37: 711-724
[Abstract][Full Text]
Christodoulou, C, Cooper, C
(2003). What is osteoporosis?. Postgrad. Med. J.
79: 133-138
[Abstract][Full Text]
Nelson, H. D., Rizzo, J., Harris, E., Cauley, J., Ensrud, K., Bauer, D. C., Orwoll, E., for the Study of Osteoporotic Fractures Research G,
(2002). Osteoporosis and Fractures in Postmenopausal Women Using Estrogen. Arch Intern Med
162: 2278-2284
[Abstract][Full Text]
Carter, N. D., Khan, K. M., McKay, H. A., Petit, M. A., Waterman, C., Heinonen, A., Janssen, P. A., Donaldson, M. G., Mallinson, A., Riddell, L., Kruse, K., Prior, J. C., Flicker, L.
(2002). Community-based exercise program reduces risk factors for falls in 65- to 75-year-old women with osteoporosis: randomized controlled trial. CMAJ
167: 997-1004
[Abstract][Full Text]
Shea, B., Wells, G., Cranney, A., Zytaruk, N., Robinson, V., Griffith, L., Ortiz, Z., Peterson, J., Adachi, J., Tugwell, P., Guyatt, G.
(2002). VII. Meta-Analysis of Calcium Supplementation for the Prevention of Postmenopausal Osteoporosis. Endocr. Rev.
23: 552-559
[Full Text]
van Abel, M., Hoenderop, J. G. J., Dardenne, O., St. Arnaud, R., van Os, C. H., van Leeuwen, H. J. P. T. M., Bindels, R. J. M.
(2002). 1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3-Independent Stimulatory Effect of Estrogen on the Expression of ECaC1 in the Kidney. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol.
13: 2102-2109
[Abstract][Full Text]
Riggs, B. L., Khosla, S., Melton, L. J. III
(2002). Sex Steroids and the Construction and Conservation of the Adult Skeleton. Endocr. Rev.
23: 279-302
[Abstract][Full Text]
Devine, A., Wilson, S. G, Dick, I. M, Prince, R. L
(2002). Effects of vitamin D metabolites on intestinal calcium absorption and bone turnover in elderly women. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.
75: 283-288
[Abstract][Full Text]
Khan, S. A., de Geus, C., Holroyd, B., Russell, A. S.
(2001). Osteoporosis Follow-up After Wrist Fractures Following Minor Trauma. Arch Intern Med
161: 1309-1312
[Abstract][Full Text]
Meier, C. R., Schlienger, R. G., Kraenzlin, M. E., Schlegel, B., Jick, H.
(2000). HMG-CoA Reductase Inhibitors and the Risk of Fractures. JAMA
283: 3205-3210
[Abstract][Full Text]
Peterson, M. G. E., Galsworthy, T., Lane, J., Wilson, P. L., Wingate, J., Lapiano, D., Andariese, J.
(2000). Maintenance of Bone Density: Outcomes Over Five Years of Attendance at an Osteoporosis Center. J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci.
55: 141M-146
[Abstract][Full Text]
Anderson, J. W., Hanna, T. J.
(1999). Impact of Nondigestible Carbohydrates on Serum Lipoproteins and Risk for Cardiovascular Disease. J. Nutr.
129: 1457-1457
[Abstract][Full Text]
FELSENFELD, A. J., RODRIGUEZ, M.
(1999). Phosphorus, Regulation of Plasma Calcium, and Secondary Hyperparathyroidism: A Hypothesis to Integrate a Historical and ModernPerspective. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol.
10: 878-890
[Full Text]
Munger, R. G, Cerhan, J. R, Chiu, B. C-H
(1999). Prospective study of dietary protein intake and risk of hip fracture in postmenopausal women. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.
69: 147-152
[Abstract][Full Text]
Ryan, A. S., Nicklas, B. J., Dennis, K. E.
(1998). Aerobic exercise maintains regional bone mineral density during weight loss in postmenopausal women. J. Appl. Physiol.
84: 1305-1310
[Abstract][Full Text]
Marttunen, M. B., Hietanen, P., Tiitinen, A., Ylikorkala, O.
(1998). Comparison of Effects of Tamoxifen and Toremifene on Bone Biochemistry and Bone Mineral Density in Postmenopausal Breast Cancer Patients. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab.
83: 1158-1162
[Abstract][Full Text]
BARNES, P. J., PEDERSEN, S., BUSSE, W. W.
(1998). Efficacy and Safety of Inhaled Corticosteroids . New Developments. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
157: S1-53
[Full Text]
Andersson, B., Mattsson, L.-A., Hahn, L., Lapidus, L., Holm, G., Bengtsson, B.-A., Bjorntorp, P.
(1997). Estrogen Replacement Therapy Decreases Hyperandrogenicity and Improves Glucose Homeostasis and Plasma Lipids in Postmenopausal Women With Noninsulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab.
82: 638-643
[Abstract][Full Text]
AGERTOFT, L., PEDERSEN, S.
(1997). Bone Mineral Density in Children with Asthma Receiving Long-term Treatment with Inhaled Budesonide. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.
157: 178-183
[Abstract][Full Text]
Reid, I. R., Ames, R. W., Evans, M. C., Gamble, G. D., Sharpe, S. J.
(1993). Effect of Calcium Supplementation on Bone Loss in Postmenopausal Women. NEJM
328: 460-464
[Abstract][Full Text]
(1991). EXERCISE PLUS HORMONE THERAPY PREVENTS BONE LOSS AFTER MENOPAUSE. JWatch General
1991: 1-1
[Full Text]
