BACKGROUND. Dyslexia is now widely believed to be a biologically based disorder that is distinct from other, less specific reading problems. According to this view, reading ability is considered to follow a bimodal distribution, with dyslexia as the lower mode. We hypothesized that, instead, reading ability follows a normal distribution, with dyslexia at the lower end of the continuum. METHODS AND RESULTS. We used data from the Connecticut Longitudinal Study, a sample survey of 414 Connecticut children who entered kindergarten in 1983 and were followed as a longitudinal cohort. Dyslexia was defined in terms of a discrepancy score, which represents the difference between actual reading achievement and achievement predicted on the basis of measures of intelligence. Data were available from intelligence tests administered in grades 1, 3, and 5 and achievement tests administered yearly in grades 1 through 6. For each child there were 108 possible discrepancy scores ([3 x 3 years] x [2 x 6 years]) based on combinations of the ability scores (full-scale, verbal, and performance IQ) in each of three years and two achievement scores (reading and mathematics) in each of six years. We demonstrated that each of the discrepancy scores followed a univariate normal distribution and that the interrelation of two different discrepancy scores followed a bivariate normal distribution. At most, only 9 of 108 discrepancy scores (8.3 percent) and 171 of 3402 pairs of discrepancy scores (5.0 percent) were significantly different (at the 5 percent level) from the expected scores--well within the expected values for data with univariate and bivariate normal distributions, respectively. We also examined the stability of dyslexia over time. The normal-distribution model predicted (and the data indicated) that only 7 of the 25 children (28 percent) classified as having dyslexia in grade 1 would also be classified as having dyslexia in grade 3. CONCLUSIONS. Reading difficulties, including dyslexia, occur as part of a continuum that also includes normal reading ability. Dyslexia is not an all-or-none phenomenon, but like hypertension, occurs in degrees. The variability inherent in the diagnosis of dyslexia can be both quantified and predicted with use of the normal-distribution model.
Source Information
Department of Pediatrics, Child Study Center, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Conn.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Siok, W. T., Niu, Z., Jin, Z., Perfetti, C. A., Tan, L. H.
(2008). From the Cover: A structural-functional basis for dyslexia in the cortex of Chinese readers. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
105: 5561-5566
[Abstract][Full Text]
Chard, D. J., Stoolmiller, M., Harn, B. A., Wanzek, J., Vaughn, S., Linan-Thompson, S., Kame'enui, E. J.
(2008). Predicting Reading Success in a Multilevel Schoolwide Reading Model: A Retrospective Analysis. J Learn Disabil
41: 174-188
[Abstract]
Wise, J. C., Sevcik, R. A., Morris, R. D., Lovett, M. W., Wolf, M.
(2007). The Relationship Among Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary, Listening Comprehension, Pre-Reading Skills, Word Identification Skills, and Reading Comprehension by Children With Reading Disabilities. JSLHR
50: 1093-1109
[Abstract][Full Text]
Justice, L. M.
(2006). Evidence-Based Practice, Response to Intervention, and the Prevention of Reading Difficulties. LSHSS
37: 284-297
[Abstract][Full Text]
Lipka, O., Lesaux, N. K., Siegel, L. S.
(2006). Retrospective Analyses of the Reading Development of Grade 4 Students with Reading Disabilities: Risk Status and Profiles Over 5 Years. J Learn Disabil
39: 364-378
[Abstract]
Fletcher, J. M., Denton, C., Francis, D. J.
(2005). Validity of Alternative Approaches for the Identification of Learning Disabilities: Operationalizing Unexpected Underachievement. J Learn Disabil
38: 545-552
[Abstract]
Lafferty, A. E., Gray, S., Wilcox, M. J.
(2005). Teaching alphabetic knowledge to pre-school children with developmental language delay and with typical language development. Child Language Teaching and Therapy
21: 263-277
[Abstract]
Siegel, L. S., Smythe, I. S.
(2005). Reflections on Research on Reading Disability with Special Attention to Gender Issues. J Learn Disabil
38: 473-477
[Abstract]
Grizzle, K. L., Simms, M. D.
(2005). Early Language Development and Language Learning Disabilities. Pediatr. Rev.
26: 274-283
[Full Text]
Francis, D. J., Fletcher, J. M., Stuebing, K. K., Lyon, G. R., Shaywitz, B. A., Shaywitz, S. E.
(2005). Psychometric Approaches to the Identification of LD: IQ and Achievement Scores Are Not Sufficient. J Learn Disabil
38: 98-108
[Abstract]
Hawken, L. S., Johnston, S. S., McDonnell, A. P.
(2005). Emerging Literacy Views and Practices: Results From a National Survey of Head Start Preschool Teachers. Topics in Early Childhood Special Education
25: 232-242
[Abstract]
Casanova, M. F., Araque, J., Giedd, J., Rumsey, J. M.
(2004). Reduced Brain Size and Gyrification in the Brains of Dyslexic Patients. J Child Neurol
19: 275-281
[Abstract]
Samuelsson, S., Lundberg, I., Herkner, B.
(2004). ADHD and Reading Disability in Male Adults: Is There a Connection?. J Learn Disabil
37: 155-168
[Abstract]
Stage, S. A., Abbott, R. D., Jenkins, J. R., Berninger, V. W.
(2003). Predicting Response to Early Reading Intervention From Verbal IQ, Reading-Related Language Abilities, Attention Ratings, and Verbal IQ Word Reading Discrepancy: Failure to Validate Discrepancy Method. J Learn Disabil
36: 24-33
[Abstract]
Terepocki, M., Kruk, R. S., Willows, D. M.
(2002). The Incidence and Nature of Letter Orientation Errors in Reading Disability. J Learn Disabil
35: 214-233
[Abstract]
Sofie, C. A., Riccio, C. A.
(2002). A Comparison of Multiple Methods for the Identification of Children with Reading Disabilities. J Learn Disabil
35: 234-244
[Abstract]
Stuebing, K. K., Fletcher, J. M., LeDoux, J. M., Lyon, G. R., Shaywitz, S. E., Shaywitz, B. A.
(2002). Validity of IQ-Discrepancy Classifications of Reading Disabilities: A Meta-Analysis. Am Educ Res J
39: 469-518
[Abstract]
Wood, F. B., Grigorenko, E. L.
(2001). Emerging Issues in the Genetics of Dyslexia: A Methodological Preview. J Learn Disabil
34: 503-511
[Abstract]
Felton, R. H.
(2001). Students with Three Types of Severe Reading Disabilities: Introduction to the Case Studies. Journal of Special Education
35: 122-124
von Karolyi, C.
(2001). Visual-Spatial Strength in Dyslexia: Rapid Discrimination of Impossible Figures. J Learn Disabil
34: 380-391
[Abstract]
Fawcett, A. J., Nicolson, R. I., Maclagan, F.
(2001). Cerebellar Tests Differentiate Between Groups of Poor Readers With and Without IQ Discrepancy. J Learn Disabil
34: 119-135
[Abstract]
Shaywitz, S. E., Holahan, J. M., Freudenheim, D. A., Fletcher, J. M., Makuch, R. W., Shaywitz, B. A.
(2001). Heterogeneity Within the Gifted: Higher IQ Boys Exhibit Behaviors Resembling Boys With Learning Disabilities. Gifted Child Quarterly
45: 16-23
[Abstract]
Habib, M.
(2000). The neurological basis of developmental dyslexia: An overview and working hypothesis. Brain
123: 2373-2399
[Abstract][Full Text]
Stanford, G., Oakland, T.
(2000). Cognitive Deficits Underlying Learning Disabilities: Research Perspectives from the United States. School Psychology International
21: 306-321
[Abstract]
Studdert-Kennedy, M., Mody, M., Brady, S.
(2000). Speech Perception Deficits in Poor Readers: A Reply to Denenberg's Critique. J Learn Disabil
33: 317-321
[Abstract]
Kavale, K. A., Forness, S. R.
(2000). What Definitions of Learning Disability Say and Don't Say: A Critical Analysis. J Learn Disabil
33: 239-256
[Abstract]
Shaywitz, S. E., Fletcher, J. M., Holahan, J. M., Shneider, A. E., Marchione, K. E., Stuebing, K. K., Francis, D. J., Pugh, K. R., Shaywitz, B. A.
(1999). Persistence of Dyslexia: The Connecticut Longitudinal Study at Adolescence. Pediatrics
104: 1351-1359
[Abstract][Full Text]
Stanovich, K. E.
(1999). The Sociopsychometrics of Learning Disabilities. J Learn Disabil
32: 350-361
[Abstract]
Nagarajan, S., Mahncke, H., Salz, T., Tallal, P., Roberts, T., Merzenich, M. M.
(1999). Cortical auditory signal processing in poor readers. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
96: 6483-6488
[Abstract][Full Text]
Helenius, P., Uutela, K., Hari, R.
(1999). Auditory stream segregation in dyslexic adults. Brain
122: 907-913
[Abstract][Full Text]
Silver, C. H., Deborah-Lynne Pennett, H., Black, J. L., Fair, G. W., Balise, R. R.
(1999). Stability of Arithmetic Disability Subtypes. J Learn Disabil
32: 108-119
[Abstract]
Badian, N. A.
(1999). Reading Disability Defined as a Discrepancy Betwveen Listening and Reading Comprehension: A Longitudinal Study of Stability, Gender Differences, and Prevalence. J Learn Disabil
32: 138-148
[Abstract]
Shaywitz, S. E.
(1998). Dyslexia. NEJM
338: 307-312
[Full Text]
Demb, J. B., Boynton, G. M., Heeger, D. J.
(1997). Brain activity in visual cortex predicts individual differences in reading performance. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
94: 13363-13366
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hall, S.J., Halperin, J.M., Schwartz, S.T., Newcorn, J.H.
(1997). Behavioral and executive functions in children with Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity disorder and reading disability. J Atten Disord
1: 235-243
[Abstract]
Aaron, P. G.
(1997). The Impending Demise of the Discrepancy Formula. REVIEW OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH
67: 461-502
[Abstract]
