|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Background Major-histocompatibility-complex (MHC) class II deficiency is an autosomal recessive primary immunodeficiency disease in which MHC class II molecules are absent. It is a genetically heterogeneous disease of gene regulation resulting from defects in several transactivating genes that regulate the expression of MHC class II genes. The mutations responsible for MHC class II deficiency are classified according to complementation group (a group in which the phenotype remains uncorrected in pairwise fusions of cells). There are three known complementation groups (A, B, and C).
Methods To elucidate the genetic defect in patients with MHC class II deficiency that was not classified genetically, we performed direct complementation assays with the three genes known to regulate the expression of MHC class II genes, CIITA, RFX5, and RFXAP, and the relevant mutations were identified in each patient.
Results Mutations in the RFXAP gene were found in three patients from unrelated families, and the resulting defect was classified as belonging to a novel complementation group (D). Transfection with the wild-type RFXAP gene restored the expression of MHC class II molecules in the patients' cells.
Conclusions Mutations in a novel MHC class II transactivating factor, RFXAP, can cause MHC class II deficiency. These mutations abolish the expression of MHC class II genes and lead to the same clinical picture of immunodeficiency as in patients with mutations in the other two MHC class II regulatory genes.
The clinical manifestations of the disease result from the lack of MHC class II molecules, but the primary genetic defect does not involve the MHC class II genes themselves or their promoters. Instead, the affected genes encode transactivating factors that regulate the expression of MHC class II genes. The demonstration that the disease does not segregate with the MHC class II locus established MHC class II deficiency as a disease of gene regulation.4,5 Although clinically homogeneous, primary MHC class II deficiency is genetically heterogeneous. This was shown by cell-fusion experiments that identified three distinct complementation groups (i.e., groups in which the phenotype remains uncorrected in pairwise fusions of cells). These groups were named A, B, and C.6,7,8 Mutant cells lacking MHC class II molecules have been produced in vitro, and they can also be classified according to complementation groups. One such mutant cell line (6.1.6) belongs to a fourth complementation group (D), which differs from the groups found thus far in MHC class II deficiency.6,7,8
MHC class II molecules present antigens to T lymphocytes and are essential for the activation of T cells. The expression of MHC class II genes is under very tight and complex regulation. Epithelial cells in the thymus, dendritic cells, and B lymphocytes constitutively express MHC class II genes. In many other types of cells, the expression of these genes can be induced by certain stimuli, especially interferon-
.9 In all these situations, the expression of MHC class II genes is controlled and directed by the MHC class II transactivator CIITA.10,11
Studies of cell lines derived from patients with MHC class II deficiency and mutant cell lines have identified three key regulatory factors: CIITA, RFX5, and RFXAP.10,11,12,13,14 CIITA is defective in complementation group A. The molecular defect in groups B, C, and D is a deficiency of regulatory factor X (RFX), a multimeric protein complex that binds to promoters of MHC class II genes.5 One subunit of the RFX complex, RFX5, is mutated in complementation group C.12 The mutant cell line 6.1.6 (complementation group D) has a mutation in RFXAP, a 36-kd subunit of the RFX complex.13 The identification of these regulatory genes has allowed us to study several patients with MHC class II deficiency whose genetic defect had not been previously classified or was thought to belong to complementation groups distinct from A, B, and C.8,15 Our results show that in all the patients with bona fide MHC class II deficiency that we have studied, the mutations responsible belong to one of the four known complementation groups A, B, C, or D.
Methods
Patients and Cell Lines
The ABI fibroblast cell line was derived from a Turkish patient (Patient 1).15 The ZM fibroblast and B-cell lines were derived from a Moroccan patient (Patient 2) (Fondanèche MC, et al.: unpublished data). The DA cell line was derived from an Algerian patient (Patient 3).16,17 Cells were cultured, transfected, selected with hygromicin, and analyzed by flow cytometry (ABI and DA cells) or immunofluorescence (ZM cells) as described previously.10,11,12,13 Transfected ABI and HeLa cells were stimulated with recombinant interferon-
(GIBCO) for 72 hours. Transfected ZM fibroblasts were treated with interferon-
for 48 hours.
Preparatory Measures and Assays
The plasmids used to transfect the ABI and ZM fibroblast-cell lines were pREP4 (Invitrogen) and pREP4RFXAP. The RFXAP complementary DNA (cDNA)13 was cloned between the BamHI and HindIII site of pREP4. For DA cells, the plasmids used for transfection were pCD10 and pCDRFXAP.13 The 32P-labeled riboprobe used to detect RFX5 messenger RNA (mRNA) was transcribed with T7 RNA polymerase from a Bluescript plasmid (Stratagene) containing a 372-bp fragment of RFX5 (nucleotides 739 to 1110). The 32P-labeled riboprobes used to detect mRNA of CI ITA, HLA-DRA, and guanylate-binding protein have been described previously.10,18,19
Preparation of whole-cell extracts,20 procedures for electrophoretic mobility shift assays,12,21 binding conditions for RFX, nuclear factor Y (NF-Y),22 and the double-stranded oligonucleotides (WX2 and Y) used as probes23,24 have been described previously. Binding reactions were carried out with 10 µg of whole-cell extract. For ABI cells, decreasing amounts of nonspecific competitor DNA were used.
Rnase Protection Experiments
Cytoplasmic RNA was extracted from 5 million cells as described previously.25 To generate the probes, the plasmids were linearized and transcribed in the presence of [32P]uridine triphosphate with T7 RNA polymerase in the case of RFX5, CIITA, and guanylate-binding protein; T3 RNA polymerase in the case of TATA-binding protein; or SP6 RNA polymerase in the case of HLA-DRA. The specific activity of the HLA-DRA probe was 30 times less than that of the other probes. For each sample, 30 µg of cytoplasmic RNA was analyzed as described previously.11
Amplification and Sequencing
Full-length RFXAP cDNA clones were isolated by a reverse-transcriptionpolymerase-chain-reaction (PCR) assay and analyzed for mutations as described previously.13 The RFXAP gene was also examined for mutations by direct sequencing of PCR-amplified fragments derived from genomic DNA. The following primers were used: RFXAPC5 (5'ATggaggcgcagggtgtag3'), which is situated at the translation-initiation codon (nucleotides 116 to 133 of RFXAP cDNA), and RFX5APDA2 (5'TGCAGGTCTTGCTCATGCTG3'), which is situated between nucleotides 521 and 540 of RFXAP cDNA. PCR was performed with the Expand high-fidelity PCR system (Boehringer Mannheim). Sequencing was performed directly with the Applied Biosystems PRISM dye terminator cycle-sequencing kit and an Applied Biosystems DNA sequencer.
Results
Defect in the Binding of RFX to MHC Class II Promoters in Patient 1
A fibroblast cell line (ABI) from Patient 1, with an unidentified genetic defect,15 was studied for the expression of mRNA for the MHC class II gene HLA-DRA and the transactivators CIITA and RFX5. Figure 1A shows that the level of RFX5 mRNA was normal in the ABI cell line, and that interferon-
induced similar degrees of expression of CIITA mRNA in ABI and control cells. By contrast, interferon-
induced the expression of HLA-DRA mRNA in control cells but not in ABI cells. Thus, in Patient 1 the molecular defect does not affect RFX5 mRNA or the inducibility of CIITA mRNA by interferon-
.
|
Effect of Transfection with the RFXAP Gene on the Expression of MHC Class II Molecules in the ABI Cell Line
In view of the defect in RFX binding in ABI cells, we investigated whether transfection with cDNA encoding the two subunits of RFX (RFX5 and RFXAP) would allow interferon-
to induce the expression of MHC class II genes in ABI cells. The cDNA encoding RFX5, the gene affected in complementation group C, had no effect (data not shown), whereas transfection with the cDNA of RFXAP enabled interferon-
to induce the expression of the HLA-DR gene in ABI cells (Figure 2A). The wild-type RFXAP gene can thus correct the defect in the expression of MHC class II in cells from Patient 1.
|
To characterize the RFXAP gene in Patient 1, the entire coding region of RFXAP mRNA from ABI cells was amplified by PCR, subcloned, and sequenced. All the cDNA clones that we isolated contained a point mutation at nucleotide 279 that converts a glutamine codon to a premature stop codon (from CAG to TAG). This mutation would lead to a severely truncated protein of only 52 amino acids. Direct sequencing of a genomic PCR fragment demonstrated that Patient 1 is homozygous for the mutated allele (Figure 2B). In this patient the defect is therefore in the same regulatory gene as the defect in the mutant cell line 6.1.6, and thus belongs to complementation group D.
Additional Defects in the Regulatory Gene RFXAP
A cell line (ZM) from Patient 2 was studied in the same way as the ABI cell line. The expression of MHC class II genes was fully corrected by transfection of ZM cells with the cDNA of RFXAP (Figure 3A), indicating that the defect in Patient 2 also belongs to complementation group D. A cell line (DA) from another, unrelated patient with MHC class II deficiency (Patient 3) was also fully corrected by transfection with the cDNA of the RFXAP gene.13
|
Discussion
MHC class II deficiency is a disease of gene regulation involving regulatory factors that are essential for the expression of MHC class II genes. CIITA, the gene affected in complementation group A (Figure 4), encodes a transactivator that does not bind to DNA and serves as a general controller of both the constitutive and inducible expression of MHC class II genes.5,10,11 The expression of CIITA is very tightly controlled by several alternative promoters.14 Mutations in the gene encoding RFX5, a subunit of the ubiquitous RFX complex, cause the defect in complementation group C (Figure 4). 12,26 Recently, a second subunit of the RFX complex, RFXAP, has been cloned.13 We found that mutations in the RFXAP gene define a novel complementation group group D (Figure 4). The genes affected in groups A (CIITA) and C (RFX5) have been mapped to chromosomes 16 and 1, respectively.5,26 Using a novel high-resolution mapping method,27 we have mapped RFXAP (group D) to chromosome 13 (Table 1). The defect in complementation group B entails the same lack of binding of the RFX protein to the X box of the promoters of MHC class II genes as in groups C and D. We have recently identified a third protein subunit within RFX, which might be affected in complementation group B.
|
|
Patient 2 is of special interest because his genetic defect has been shown by cell-fusion experiments to be related to the defect in five other patients from three unrelated families (Fondanèche MC, et al.: unpublished data). Thus, at least eight patients from six unrelated families have a defect in the RFXAP gene and thus belong to complementation group D (Table 1). This complementation group is the largest after group B. It also appears that the four complementation groups account for all currently known types of true MHC class II deficiency (Table 1). A family with an almost asymptomatic form of immunodeficiency and with only selective defects in the expression of certain HLA class II genes has been described,28,29 but this atypical phenotype probably represents a distinct syndrome.
The clinical manifestations and immunologic abnormalities in MHC class II deficiency are similar in all four complementation groups,2,3,5 probably because the distinct regulatory factors involved in this disease, although having very different structures and functions, are all essential for the control of the expression of MHC class II genes. Interestingly, the three regulatory genes affected in MHC class II deficiency, CIITA, RFX5, and RFXAP, are not only absolutely essential, with no bypass or alternative pathways, but also highly specific for MHC class II genes. These properties are unusual for transcriptional regulatory factors, which generally control multiple genes and thus have pleiotropic effects.
Symptomatic and prophylactic treatment of infections in patients with MHC class II deficiency does not prevent progressive organ dysfunction, and death is usual before the age of 18 years. Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation is considered the treatment of choice, but the success rate is lower than that for other immunodeficiency syndromes.30 Now that three of the genes affected in MHC class II deficiency have been identified, gene therapy becomes a possibility in this disease. In the case of complementation group A, it would not be possible to reproduce the complex pattern of physiologic control of CIITA expression,14 and uncontrolled expression of CIITA is likely to lead to aberrant expression of MHC class II molecules. In the case of the novel complementation group D, however, the RFXAP gene is not regulated, and gene therapy can now be envisaged.
Supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation and the Louis Jeantet Foundation.
We are indebted to M.C. Fondanèche, E. Barras, and M. Zufferey for expert technical assistance.
Source Information
From the Louis Jeantet Laboratory of Molecular Genetics, Department of Genetics and Microbiology, University of Geneva Medical School, Geneva (J.V., W.R., B.M.); INSERM Unité 429, Hôpital NeckerEnfants Malades, Paris (B.L.-G., A.F.); and the Department of Immunohematology and Bloodbank, University Hospital Leiden, Leiden, the Netherlands (P.E.).
Address reprint requests to Dr. Mach at the Department of Genetics and Microbiology, University of Geneva Medical School, 1 rue Michel-Servet, CH-1211 Geneva 4, Switzerland.
References
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
This article has been cited by other articles:
HOME | SUBSCRIBE | SEARCH | CURRENT ISSUE | PAST ISSUES | COLLECTIONS | PRIVACY | TERMS OF USE | HELP | beta.nejm.org Comments and questions? Please contact us. The New England Journal of Medicine is owned, published, and copyrighted © 2009 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved. |