BACKGROUND. Endoscopic sclerotherapy is an accepted treatment for bleeding esophageal varices, but it is associated with substantial local and systemic complications. Endoscopic ligation, a new form of endoscopic treatment for bleeding varices, may be safer. We compared the effectiveness and safety of the two techniques. METHODS. In this randomized trial we compared endoscopic sclerotherapy and endoscopic ligation in 129 patients with cirrhosis who had proved bleeding from esophageal varices. Sixty-five patients were treated with sclerotherapy, and 64 with ligation. Initial treatment for acute bleeding was followed by elective retreatment to eradicate varices. The patients were followed for a mean of 10 months, during which we determined the incidence of complications and recurrences of bleeding, the number of treatments needed to eradicate varices, and survival. RESULTS. Active bleeding at the first treatment was controlled by sclerotherapy in 10 of 13 patients (77 percent) and by ligation in 12 of 14 patients (86 percent). Slightly more sclerotherapy-treated patients had recurrent hemorrhage during the study (48 percent vs. 36 percent for the ligation-treated patients, P = 0.072). The eradication of varices required a lower mean (+/- SD) number of treatments with ligation (4 +/- 2 vs. 5 +/- 2, P = 0.056) than with sclerotherapy. The mortality rate was significantly higher in the sclerotherapy group (45 percent vs. 28 percent, P = 0.041), as was the rate of complications (22 percent vs. 2 percent, P less than 0.001). The complications of sclerotherapy were predominantly esophageal strictures, pneumonias, and other infections. CONCLUSIONS. Patients with cirrhosis who have bleeding esophageal varices have fewer treatment-related complications and better survival rates when they are treated by esophageal ligation than when they are treated by sclerotherapy.
Source Information
Department of Surgery, University of Colorado, Denver.
This article has been cited by other articles:
Lo, G-H, Chen, W-C, Wang, H-M, Lin, C-K, Chan, H-H, Tsai, W-L, Cheng, L-C, Yu, H-C, Tsay, F-W
(2009). Low-dose terlipressin plus banding ligation versus low-dose terlipressin alone in the prevention of very early rebleeding of oesophageal varices. Gut
58: 1275-1280
[Abstract][Full Text]
Villanueva, C., Minana, J., Ortiz, J., Gallego, A., Soriano, G., Torras, X., Sainz, S., Boadas, J., Cusso, X., Guarner, C., Balanzo, J.
(2001). Endoscopic Ligation Compared with Combined Treatment with Nadolol and Isosorbide Mononitrate to Prevent Recurrent Variceal Bleeding. NEJM
345: 647-655
[Abstract][Full Text]
Sharara, A. I., Rockey, D. C.
(2001). Gastroesophageal Variceal Hemorrhage. NEJM
345: 669-681
[Full Text]
BURROUGHS, A K, PATCH, D W, JALAN, R, HAYES, P C
(2001). Management of variceal haemorrhage in cirrhotic patients Reply. Gut
48: 738a-740
[Full Text]
Gow, P J, Chapman, R W
(2001). Modern management of oesophageal varices. Postgrad. Med. J.
77: 75-81
[Abstract][Full Text]
Jalan, R, Hayes, P C
(2000). UK guidelines on the management of variceal haemorrhage in cirrhotic patients. Gut
46: iii1-15
[Full Text]
Junquera, F, Lopez-Talavera, J C, Mearin, F, Saperas, E, Videla, S, Armengol, J-R, Esteban, R, Malagelada, J-R
(2000). Somatostatin plus isosorbide 5-mononitrate versus somatostatin in the control of acute gastro-oesophageal variceal bleeding: a double blind, randomised, placebo controlled clinical trial. Gut
46: 127-132
[Abstract][Full Text]
Sarin, S. K., Lamba, G. S., Kumar, M., Misra, A., Murthy, N. S.
(1999). Comparison of Endoscopic Ligation and Propranolol for the Primary Prevention of Variceal Bleeding. NEJM
340: 988-993
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hepworth, C C, Kadirkamanathan, S S, Gong, F, Swain, C P
(1998). A randomised controlled comparison of injection, thermal, and mechanical endoscopic methods of haemostasis on mesenteric vessels. Gut
42: 462-469
[Abstract][Full Text]
Jenkins, S A, Shields, R, Davies, M, Elias, E, Turnbull, A J, Bassendine, M F, James, O F W, Iredale, J P, Vyas, S K, Arthur, M J P, Kingsnorth, A N, Sutton, R
(1997). A multicentre randomised trial comparing octreotide and injection sclerotherapy in the management and outcome of acute variceal haemorrhage. Gut
41: 526-533
[Abstract][Full Text]
Hayes, P C
(1996). The coming of age of band ligation for oesophageal varices. BMJ
312: 1111-1112
[Full Text]
McNair, A N B, Tibbs, C J, Williams, R
(1995). Recent Advances: Hepatology. BMJ
311: 1351-1355
[Full Text]
Wiliams, S G J, Westaby, D
(1994). Fortnightly Review: Management of variceal haemorrhage. BMJ
308: 1213-1217
[Full Text]
Rossle, M., Haag, K., Ochs, A., Sellinger, M., Noldge, G., Perarnau, J.-M., Berger, E., Blum, U., Gabelmann, A., Hauenstein, K., Langer, M., Gerok, W.
(1994). The Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Stent-Shunt Procedure for Variceal Bleeding. NEJM
330: 165-171
[Abstract][Full Text]
Spence, R. K.
(1993). Transfusion Practices in Vascular Surgery. PERSPECT VASC SURG ENDOVASC THER
6: 14-43
(1992). ENDOSCOPIC LIGATION BEATS SCLEROTHERAPY FOR BLEEDING VARICES. JWatch General
1992: 3-3
[Full Text]
Previous
