Health policy decisions are often controversial, and the recentdetermination by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) notto grant over-the-counter status to the emergency contraceptivePlan B was no exception. Some physicians decried the decisionas a troubling clash of science, politics, and morality.1 Otherpractitioners, citing safety, heralded the agency's prudence.2Public sentiment mirrored both views. Regardless, the decisionpreserved a major barrier to the acquisition of emergency contraception the need to obtain and fill a prescription within anarrow window of efficacy. Six states have lowered that hurdleby allowing pharmacists to dispense emergency contraceptionwithout . . . [Full Text of this Article]
Arguments in Favor of a Pharmacist's Right to Object
Pharmacists Can and Should Exercise Independent Judgment
Professionals Should Not Forsake Their Morals as a Condition of Employment
Conscientious Objection is Integral to Democracy
Arguments Against a Pharmacist's Right to Object
Pharmacists Choose to Enter a Profession Bound by Fiduciary Duties
Emergency Contraception is Not an Abortifacient
Pharmacists' Objections Significantly Affect Patients' Health
Refusal Has Great Potential for Abuse and Discrimination
Toward Balance
Source Information
From the Yale University School of Medicine (J.C.) and Wiggin and Dana (K.B.) both in New Haven, Conn.
Curlin, F. A., Lawrence, R. E., Chin, M. H., Lantos, J. D.
(2007). Religion, Conscience, and Controversial Clinical Practices. NEJM
356: 593-600
[Abstract][Full Text]
Mears, B. J.
(2005). Refusal to Provide Essential Care: Duties of Providers. AAP Grand Rounds
14: 30-30
[Full Text]
Waxman, J., Laser, R., Calis, K. A., Pucino, F. Jr., Restrepo, M. L., Manasse, H. R. Jr., Cantor, J., Baum, K.
(2005). Pharmacists and Emergency Contraception. NEJM
352: 942-944
[Full Text]
Fincham, J. E, Harris, C. E, Fassett, W. E, Richards, W.
(2005). Over-the-Counter Availability of Plan B Emergency Contraception: Further Discussion and Commentary. The Annals of Pharmacotherapy
39: 346-351
[Abstract][Full Text]